Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Tnsharpshooter

Minelab Service Rep Seems Is Watching At Least Some Forums

Recommended Posts

Rick Kempf    248

Minelab - as far as I can determine - don't assemble their detectors.  They are built by a subcontractor in Malayasia  There is no pile of parts and sub-assemblies lying around in Australia or anywhere else.  This is a problem for them.  Quick repairs require that  commectors, mechanical and electronic parts, circuit boards are readily available at service centers.  For their modern machines, that seems to be a problem for them. This is a problem which is not easy, cheap or quick to fix. 

Glad to hear that they have realized that this is a problem which can and will impact brand loualty.  Hope they move fast and effectively.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

strick    799

Another thing.. I read on another  forum that kellyco will put people ahead of the line on repairs if they pay a expedition fee. I don't know if that is true or not I'll try and find where I saw that...Looking at the Orville Dam news right now... Not good calling for evacuations down stream. 

strick

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tnsharpshooter    174

Thanks for the link Steve.

I wonder from a unit sales number standpoint worldwide,,,,how does the USA stack up here???

I would think we would be at or near the top.

Would have expected they would sure not have slighted the USA for repair support overall.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Steve Herschbach    7,843

The big picture is that Minelab benefitted immensely from the big African gold rush a few years back. The GPX 4500 could not be built fast enough to supply demand. Like all gold rushes the bubble popped, and Minelab sales plunged as a result. It is very hard for any company to deal with seriously declining revenues, and Minelab cut expenses everywhere they could. Service is often the first thing to suffer under those circumstances at any company. A smart company cuts deep and fast, but usually goes too far. Minelab did execute a significant turn around, and sales are once again climbing. Now there is some damage to repair also going forward.

This is all fairly public knowledge. Minelab is owned by Codan, a publicly traded company. Much can be learned reading Codan company reports. The U.S. is a very large market, but most growth is occurring elsewhere. Africa has actually been the big growth market as of late, which is why all the focus by companies to make detectors for the Africa market.

Here you think in terms of owning a detector for decades, and why won't they service that 20 year old detector. In Africa, they wore the darn thing out after a year, threw it away, and got another one!

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Geotech    130
1 hour ago, Reno Chris said:

Tnsharpshooter - some problems occur with part availability. If your detector needs a new XYZ17 transistor, and the manufacturer stopped making them a year ago, the truth is that it can be near impossible to get additional obsolete parts like that. This situation affects all detector manufacturers.

This excuse is greatly overused by companies. Custom & semi-custom parts (keypad, display, etc) and sole-source parts, yes. But most electronic parts are either multi-sourced, or easily substituted with something close enough.

The actual reality is, most companies (and not just detector companies) don't repair at the component level, they repair at the board level. That is, they swap out a whole board. When a product is discontinued, they normally set aside a stock of replacement boards sufficient for x-years of repair. Once those boards are gone, no more repair.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tnsharpshooter    174

I am aware of how expensive logistics,,,repair facilities,,,parts storage can be.

Learned a lot about this in AF.

I think detector manufacturers should be looking hard at designing their detectors for easier maintenance/repairs.

Consider modular design,,,and being such,,,imagine a detector owner could possibly exchange out their module with a module of off someone else's detector,,,,troubleshooting.

Could save loads of $$ and time with shipping and repairs.

Or if not the swapping,,,at least a manufacturer based on malfunction can get a replacement module out to customer.

Now saying this,,,is obviously easier than doing,,,detector strength,,looks,,feel,,and durability can't be compromised,,,weight too probably.

And must be user friendly with parts exchange-- not complicated.

Xp in a way enjoys this in a way with Deus.

Detector companies,,,,need to think lean and mean.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Steve Herschbach    7,843

They generally do think that way. First Texas for instance and Garrett certainly, just swap out a board and you are done. There is not much in a F75 or AT Pro.

This is an issue but honestly, I have owned a lot of detectors and they rarely fail.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Rick Kempf    248

Detector companies are cursed with customers who want to use their products for 20 years.  OK for L.L. Bean, but for electronic devices it's a problem. Like Carl said, once the supply of set aside replacement boards is gone, it's all over.

whites is famous for having rat-holed bits and pieces of detectors.  More than once I have been offered a repair on an obselete detector by ising a "servicable" used part.  I happily said OK, but frankly, that's not a very rational way to run a business.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Tnsharpshooter    174

I'm presuming for example all the detector electronics in F75 are in the head of detector.

If this is so,,,,wonder if the head could be screwed off by a user and replaced.

Even looking at non USB capable detectors,,,a firmware upgrade,,,,just buy the updated head.  Or just send in the head for upgrade.

I wonder for example,,,just how much shipping $$$ were spent on F75 units upgraded to DST,,,,and the MX Sport with its firmware updates and screen cracks??

Shipping entire detectors back and forth.

Granted MX sport being waterproof,,,an easily removable head might not be feasible.

But I think the point here is still a good one.

This would be a departure from the norm,,,but I think a manufacturer could benefit.

Where there is a will, there is a way.

A lot of this here,,,I could label as a CYA concept for a manufacturer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Reno Chris    1,102
1 hour ago, Geotech said:

The actual reality is, most companies (and not just detector companies) don't repair at the component level,

I've had a single diode that went bad on a Minelab detector I owned replaced in the past. I agree with you that this is not the norm but it does happen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By GB_Amateur
      Although this post has some relevance to the threads of excitement regarding the just announced Minelab Equinox (wonder what Chevy thinks about that name...), it really isn't directly on topic so I started a new thread instead.  You'll see the relevance in my final comments, after the 'facts'.
      Just back from Colorado and I mentioned in another thread that part of my trip was attending two events by Denver's Eureka Treasure Hunters Club (http://www.eurekathc.org/):  The monthly (2nd Friday evening) club meeting and the annual Coinhuna -- free(!) hunt for members only.  I slid through a loophole(?) to get to participate in the latter.
      There were 50-60 attendees of the club meeting and a similar number for the hunt, and most were overlap = same people.  Being a detector zealot (thanks at least in part to some posters here who will remain anonymous), I spent some time walking around prior to the hunt to see what detectors people were using.  I was surprised at the results of this informal survey, but maybe you won't be.  NOTE:  I did not do a scientific tally, so the numbers aren't 100% accurate, but they aren't that far off.  I do know detector brands, although models (especially older ones) not so much.  Here is my view and recollection.  I'm assuming ~60 detectors were viewed (some brought more than one):
      White's (mostly TRX, IDX, DFX) -- 35.
      Garrett (AT Pro, Ace [various], AT Max, AT gold, older green models whose names I didn't catch/recognize) -- 15.
      First Texas (F75, T2, Gold Bug Pro -- that was me!) -- 4.
      Tesoro (Lobo Super Track, other I didn't recognize) -- 2.
      XP (Deus) -- 2.
      Minelab, Nokta, Makro, Bounty Hunter -- 0!
      Ok, what's up with this? First off, it was a competition hunt.  But I only saw 9 of the long skinny rectangular coils, 8 White's Bigfeet and one Tesoro cleansweep.  That still leaves a whopping 26 White's detectors with tyical general use coils.  While in the Denver area I also went by Gold-N-Detectors (in Golden, catch the play on letters?).  Now we may be getting somewhere.  They have pretty much all of White's current models on display along with several Garretts and about four Tesoros.  The only FTP I saw was a Teknetix T2 black.  Didn't notice any other brands.  They sell detectors at full retail with, AFAIK, no negotiating.  So I'm sure not everyone at the club has bought their detectors at that outlet.  However, there is a strong influence, and if you see one you like at the store you can just go online and get a discount.
      There is also a 'mentoring' effect.  For example, a person shows up at the club meeting wanting to get into the hobby and is influenced by what detector to get based upon the possessions of the experienced club members.
      Does country loyalty also play a part?  I think it does; just read some comments you see here occasionally.  But that's not the whole story.  Why only 4 First Texas detectors in the lot?  Last I looked Los Banos and El Paso are still on this side of the wall.  (oops, might get in trouble for that comment...)
      There are quite a few things that make the detectorprospector.com site unique compared to (or at least quite different from) other sites:  1) international participation; 2) dominated by gold prospectors; 3) more sophisticated(?) when it comes to understanding and using detectors; 4) more oriented towards the professional end of the spectrum than the hobby/weekender other extreme.  Most if not all of these give Minelab (and probably Nokta/Makro) a bigger audience/following.
      Even if the Equinox is the best thing since sliced bread (and it might be; I'm not taking sides), I don't think it's going to put the other guys out of business.  In fact, I doubt it's going to knock Garrett off the back cover of just about every treasure hunting magazine (and that includes ICMJ).  There are more things that go into market share than the performance of the product, although it certainly is a big factor.
       
    • By Steve Herschbach
      From https://www.whiteselectronics.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/2017_5.pdf, page 3....
      "NEW MACHINE ON THE HORIZON?
      Rumors have been swirling about what machine White’s will release next. Some speculate that it could be a 12kHz “MX Maxxx” sold with a $200 higher price tag. Others imagine White’s going back to its roots, releasing an old-school BFO machine that weighs 8 lbs and runs on 4 C-cell batteries.
      Inside sources seem to point to some kind of mid-priced, high-performance detector aimed at customers who need a deep-seeking machine at an affordable price point. Only time will tell."

    • By Tnsharpshooter
      Don't think I've seen this posted yet.
      https://www.minelab.com/usa/go-minelabbing/news?article=319086
      06 Sep 2017
      Minelab Americas relocates to Naperville, IL.
      Minelab Americas has moved to a new office space in Naperville, Illinois commencing Friday 1 September, 2017.  
      The new office has premier facilities including sales, marketing and operations areas, warehouse and a brand new showroom displaying Minelab's extensive range of metal detectors.
      The new address is:
      123 Ambassador Drive, Suite 123
      Naperville, IL  60540

      Our Minelab Americas phone number remains the same: 1-630-401-8150
    • By Norvic
      http://theleadsouthaustralia.com.au/mining-resources/minelab-continues-to-lead-way-in-search-for-gold/
      Note the comment about what is coming out later this year.
    • By Mark Gillespie
      https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B9Fp_V3TXDyaaUJDWVluUkVKOWs/view
       
    • By Steve Herschbach

      White's Electronics just started their fall "Garage Sale" with a number of what I think are some incredible deals. As an ex-dealer I should know! The main one that caught my eye is the White's GMT package, new with full warranty, for less than normal dealer cost.
      White's GMT Reg $799.95
      6" Concentric Coil Reg $149.95
      Digging Tool Reg $39.95
      Backpack Reg $99.95
      Total Full Price $1089.80 On Sale for $450 TOO LATE, SOLD OUT!
      I cannot see how anybody with even a thought of getting a GMT can get a better deal than this! If you check the Garage Sale link above you will also see the White's V3i at about 1/3 off plus other great deals.

×