Jump to content
phoenix

I Don`t Understand What Minelab Is Doing

Recommended Posts

I guess we can wonder all we like but Minelab are very good at 🤐 So we may never know & most likely never will. We can only do what we can do with what is on offer to us. Right now it is what is happening with these X coils & doing the adapter plug. People will always buy the latest in detectors no matter the cost to get that edge to be first in best dressed before they become mainstream. That is the addiction with gold fever. Until that "new" gold detector comes out from Minelab, or whoever, then X coils & adapter plugs it is. They obviously are doing the trick to scratch that itch.👍

Good luck out there

JW 🤠

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Thats the problem no competition, they locked it all up with Patents

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Re minelab putting chip in coil conection, they were obviously hoping to or are still going to produce more coils.   Look at there previous machines, there is so many after market coils that can plug in and go and look at the profits that they lost by not producing them themselves. Business sense tells me that if you develop a product you want to make the most out of it. If I owned minelab I would want to make as many $$$'s as possible out of my investment.

But for us users we always want more benifits, power, depth, whatever so we try and modify to our advantage.  I for one never thought twice about cutting my lead coil and trying a competitor made coil. And very happy as well.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Travelergold said:

  I for one never thought twice about cutting my lead coil and trying a competitor made coil.

Sure, trying a competitor coil is what it's all about - having to risk your machine in any way seems odd but I'm all for these x-coils if they are the only game in town.

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of the things I learned from my trip to Australia is that they, like many Americans like to modify things.  I could see this in the cars and equipment and trailers and agricultural machinery.  This spirit of modification and innovation has to have come in part from the gold miners coming from all over the world with their own ideas and then adapting to the bush realities.  The same thing is happening in WA now and will continue forever.

We wonder why there is not 'open source' access to Minelab technology when it seems to have made the computer world bigger and more competitive.  I think Minelab might be trying to act more like Apple rather than Android.  They are different business models.  Apple has few business partners and Android has many.

I'd like to have Minelab open up the Z and also make available their next technology.  Licensing would be great if China and other knockoff countries would license rather than steal which is the case now.  Innovation can also turn into theft and loss of shareholder and company value if protections are not considered.

Are they pleased by the Xcoil success?  Probably not but with modifications to their existing technology as Phrunt has said it may give a longer life to the Z.  Do I think they have an Xcoil on their test benches right now?  Yes.  Could they make a deal with the Russians?  Yes.

Will any of these things happen?  Who knows.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest AussieDigs

Minelab still yet to produce coils for the Z? Bit late to the party! They should have been popping them out years ago which would also solve some warranty concerns.

Minelab obviously have their reasons which we’ll continue to shake our head at.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What metal detector company should Minelab imitate? Do we have a better example?  Are any of them producing too many great machines at a discount price?

Some of us are making lemonade and some of us are just doing business with the tools we have.

Until we can become successful alchemists we are living in the age of the best metal detectors ever made.  Let's encourage the companies to be even better with the promise of "we'll buy it if you make a better machine. "

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

4 years ago it was sometimes hard to ask a question that might be construed by some as questioning ML products or business. Often required was a preface - "I love my Minelab, but..." in order to get a serious discussion.

Today we now have photo montages of instructions on how to hardware hack and bypass their IP security to run a product which has apparantly bypassed their licensing department in a way not so different from some Chinese business practices. Except we do it for them. 

Things can sure change quick with the prospect of a little better performance.

I'm curious, is the DOD design patented too as part of some of their broader GPZ patents? Or is it a gray area? Might that be why they have not gained licensing? If so, is this Russian company doing anything so different than the Chinese do with IP theft? I mean, I'm buying an X Coil too just like a lot of people because there is literally no other option, but as much as we don't hear from Minelab we've heard equally little about this actual Russian company. I mean, I'll do what I please with my GPZ since I paid for it, but still, so many unknowns... Should these things be discussed or are they irrelevant?

Absurdity abounds.

However, I'm reminded a little of the fight in court here in the US involving farmers against John Deere and the right to modify and repair equipment you purchase, plus have access to firmware and not be locked out of it. We may soon have legislation saying exactly what is and isn't right there, some states I believe already do.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's entirely possible to love one's MineLab detector and disagree the MineLab company-level of customer communication. It doesn't make sense to be so opaque. In the line of business I worked in we tried to provide the answers before the questions needed to be asked because sooner or later trust becomes a big part of the ongoing business equation.

 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Would love to try a Nugget finder coil 17x11 on my zed. I went from a 5000 series with an older series nugget finder coil. Great combo and found plenty. But now im going over areas ive already walked over and picking up what I missed. Just wish the standard zed coils are a bit lighter. 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Mop
      A Minelab dealer down Geelong way put up the below post about an Aussie company starting to make GPZ coils.
      Interesting timing, wonder if the Russian guys have forced Minelabs hand to allow a local 3rd party to make coils.
      Here is the link to the facebook page https://www.facebook.com/luckystrikegold/
      Not looking to start a fight here, just sharing info. I don't care what coils everyone wants to run lol
      Lucky Strike Gold
        Brand new GPZ coil coming soon! 🤩
      There is a rumour in the wind that an Australian company will soon be making GPZ 7000 coils.
      At present there are only Russian made after market coils being made, so hold off and bag yourself a genuine Aussie made one. They will be cheaper than the Russian coils and, as always, very well made.
       
    • By Rob Allison
      Hello All,
         Out here in Arizona, USA, it's been very hot and now humid as the Monsoons are right around the corner.  That being said, I have been poking around an old placer location loaded with iron rubbish in search for overlooked gold nuggets.  I have made it a point to start very early, right at day break and hunt until the heat runs me out (typically 4-5 hours).  I was using the Minelab GPZ 7000 and placering a wash bottom down to bedrock like the old-timers would.  I'm lucky every so often to get a nugget here and there wedged in the bedrock cracks/crevices that the old-timers missed or overlooked.  It's always a mystery to wonder what the old-timers really discovered in some of these really rich coarse gold placer areas.  

      I'm not sure of the rules about Youtube videos, but I have attached two of them for your viewing.  Hope some of you that are not able to get out right now can enjoy the adventure with me.
       
       
    • By geof_junk
      More speculation.
      http://golddetecting.forumotion.net/t26580-new-gpz7000-aussie-made-coil-rumour
    • By Jonathan Porter
      I go about Ferrite balancing a bit differently to what is shown or advised, this is my own preference and is to do with Saturation noise and Salt signals, especially with the X coils because they can Saturate quite badly. 
      Instead of the Octopus wobble I briskly (not too brisk) wave the coil over the ferrite from left to right under the blue sticker at the front of the GPZ 14 coil, this is with the Quick Trak button depressed of course. DO NOT scrub the coil on the Ferrite this is because there is always a bit of residual signal especially in Saturable ground, once the ferrite noise dissipates I release QT and pump the coil to one side (make sure you are in Semi-Auto GB mode), this then gives the GB accuracy as a DOD coil will always sound quiet from side to side even if the GB is out, once there is no noise up and down then come over the Ferrite again to check if there is signal and repeate the process using QT if there is. Pump the coil to one side again and check the Ferrite again. This whole process should take 20 seconds, eventually you will get no ground signal up and down (Ground Noise) and minimal signal over the Ferrite. 
      If the ground has BAD Saturation signal the Saturation signal will be magnified up through the centre of the Ferrite thereby preventing you from getting the coil close enough to actually balance the Ferrite out fully, in other words the detector will be trying to balance out the Saturation signal and not the X signal off the Ferrite.

      I also recommend users adopt the GB configured to their USER button approach and to go into Manual mode when checking deep targets or committing to dig, leaving the GPZ in Semi-Auto will allow the GB to drift either through exposure to the pick whilst digging or just general drift through the coil not moving, either way the GB will be out which is not obvious unless you pump the coil. 

      JP
    • By phoenix
      A couple of months ago I put out a call for the parts list for the WM12 because my original WM12 was taking forever to charge.          At the same time I bought the replacement battery, I also bought some heavier charging cables because I have about half a dozen devices that all use the same cable. I bought cables that were listed as suitable for external hard drives and they were about 6 bucks each. Because I kept changing cables on different devices I don`t even know now what cables came with the WM12.         Anyway, with the heavier charging cables my original WM12 now charges QUICKER than the newer WM12, so I don`t need to fit the battery.        Maybe, if your WM12 is getting sluggish charging, it may not be the battery, it may be the cable breaking down.   Just a thought.    Dave
       

×
×
  • Create New...