Jump to content
Skookum

Using SDC 2300 Or GPZ 7000 Or Both?

Using SDC 2300 or GPZ 7000 or both?  

14 members have voted

  1. 1. Do you primarily use (more than 95% of the time):

    • A GPZ 7000.
    • An SDC 2300.
    • Both an SDC and a GPZ.
      0
    • This poll isn't fair because it doesn't include the GPX series!


Recommended Posts

This poll is designed to see who is currently using either the Minelab SDC or GPZ detectors with a component of identifying anyone who actively uses both.  (I hypothesize there may be a selection bias in this forum in favor of more detectorists who use the GPZ even though sales of the SDC are much higher.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Okay, it’s time to reveal some bias in creating this post/poll.  Both a GPZ and an SDC have somehow come into my possession.  I’ve used the 7000, but the 2300 remains unused in it’s box. 

I’m curious to hear from anyone that’s had experience using both. Even more so, I’m wondering if anyone has kept both. To the point, are there any convincing (notice not justifiable) reasons to keep both?  Certainly, the easy answer is to use both and see. Different folks like different strokes. However, since the 2300 is still sitting pretty in box, if it’s redundant or secondary to the 7000, perhaps selling it unused is best.  

Looking back in the forum, I found Steve’s detector poll from several years ago. The two most commonly owned detectors were both of these mentioned here. I didn’t see discussion exposing how many people owned both. But, I believe it said many people had more than one PI. With the time that has passed since that poll, results might be different now.  For instance, I hypothesize that with enough time a given hobbyist would settle in on or the other. Perhaps not. Thoughts?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Depends on the terrain in your area.  In the brush and forest, Its easier to use 2300.  Love my Z but i find i only use it most in the desert, although i have identified some spots in the woods to use it.  2300 was my first “good” detector and I have found my best and most gold with it.  I have thought of going with the coiltek coils and dropping the Z but only based on what I have read I currently don’t think it is the route for me.  Today I’m heading out with all 3.  Nox, SDC and Z and after dinking around will pick the best to use.  I have been in garbage lately so the Nox has helped me cherry pick.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The SDC will hit smaller gold than the GPZ and handles some hot rocks better that the GPZ struggles with. If you have larger deeper gold and lots of smaller gold then having both may be worth your while. If you prefer to concentrate on larger, deeper gold and only have so much time to devote to detecting, then a GPZ only may be the way to go. Some places however only have very small gold and so the SDC only may be the better choice. It all just depends on the person and situation, there is no right or wrong answer. Accessory coils are available that blur the line between the two models even further.

Do you need a heavy salmon rod or a fly fishing rod or both? Do you need a little car or an off-road truck or both? Do you need a shotgun or rifle or both?

The question is not what other people need, it’s what do you need? Only your own situation and circumstances plus how much money you want to have invested in detectors can determine that.


 

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had to pick 3, as when Gold Detecting my split is something along the lines of

GPZ - 50%

GPX - 25%

SDC - 15%

Gold Kruzer - 10%

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for your replies. It’s probably a really common question for which detector is “best”.  An epiphany I’m having right now is that maybe one of the challenges in prospecting is learning what exactly are your needs.  Here’s a theory that I might abandon with time.

When your ignorance quotient is high, your needs quotient is low. Then as your ignorance begins to decrease (from learning), your needs grow. And, finally, when your ignorance seems to be at its lowest, then your needs decrease, again.  It might even be a cycle. Right now I may be in the second phase, so that makes me both curious and needy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Skookum said:

It’s probably a really common question for which detector is “best”.

You got that righ! :laugh:

The way most detectorists with experience look at it is that detectors are tools in a toolbox. I’ve had up to a dozen detectors at a time, each for very specific uses. I really worked hard on narrowing that down, but anything less than four really crimps my style. It’s like asking “what is best, the pliers, the screwdriver, the box knife, or the hammer?” It does depend on the job at hand, and whether you want to invest in Craftsman tools or Snap-On. If you do multiple types of detecting and are serious about it, it is hard to settle on just one detector.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By phrunt
      I often wondered why X-coils came out of Russia, I know Russia has a big interest in metal detectors and has a large user base of metal detectors but I always assumed it was relics and coins that were big there like in a lot of Europe.  I never knew Russia was a country with a lot of gold.  Then I looked it up and to my surprise Russia is the 3rd largest gold producer in the world.  
      A caption from a website about Russian Gold.
      Russia recently established itself as the 3th largest gold producing nation in the world, behind China and Australia. With over 11% of the earth’s total land mass, Russia is also estimated to have the 3rd largest gold reserves in the world, with much of that gold yet to be recovered. An archaic regulatory process has limited development of many lode resources throughout the country by various mining companies. Despite these setbacks, Russia is considered to have some of the best potential for future development for gold mining in the coming decades.

      You'll see in 2018 Russia was only just behind Australia in gold production with China in first place.  Sadly New Zealand doesn't even make the list 😞
      Russia is also known for very large nuggets, some of the known big nuggets are:
      A 14-pound gold nugget called the “Devil’s Ear Nugget” was discovered in 2014.
      A 22-pound gold nugget was found as recently as 2017.
      Russia’s largest gold nugget – a 79-pounder was found in the southern Ural Mountains.
      You can read about it on this website
      Now that I know these facts it's no surprise at all X-coils came from Russia,  It's also no surprise that the manufacturer of the X-coils is himself a prospector, and a very successful one too.
      Here is a couple of videos of him finding some large nuggets using the 12" Spiral wound X-coil on his GPZ.
      And some of the Gold he found recently.


      Now it all makes sense why the X-coils came from Russia.   It makes my little sub gram nugget finds look very tiny 🙂
       
    • By flakmagnet
      Has anyone else had this happen? I was using the same settings I use in this area I go to. My tuning process was the same, but the last time I tuned, the ferrite wouldn't balance out. The detector still worked great but I couldn't figure out why it wouldn't balance the ferrite out. 
      Should I have done a factory reset or something and just put in all the settings again? 
      Suggestions?
      Thanks.
       
    • By Lunk
      Hi all,
      It’s been awhile since my last post, but I’ll be sharing some knowledge and anecdotes more often, now that my summer job is a thing of the past and I’m free to once again roam the desert southwest, wielding the power of the mighty Zed to unearth nature’s golden treasures.
      I was carefully gridding (or - in deference to Gerry in Idaho - crawling) an old nugget patch during a recent trip to the far flung reaches of Nevada’s golden triangle, when the hypnotic drone of the threshold was suddenly broken by a sharp, double “wee-ooh, wee-ooh”. This type of response typically heralds a small and shallow target, usually within six inches of the surface. “Most likely a boot tack or bird shot”, I thought to myself as I crouched down and scraped an inch or two of the dry and dusty desert soil away from the target zone with my pick. Another swing of the detector coil indicated that I had moved the target, and a quick sifting of the material with the hand scoop revealed a small yellow nugget...the first catch of the day! A few more of these shallow pickers were dug during the the next couple of hours, and then I heard a faint, single “wee-ooh”. Knowing that this meant a bit larger target at depth, I went to work hacking into the densely packed soil with my pick until...well, I’ll let this short video tell the rest of the story:
      https://www.dropbox.com/s/zzmm1pgdrpaswe7/Nugget dig.mov?dl=0
      The actual weight of the nugget turned out to be 5.6 grams, bringing the total for the day to over a quarter of an ounce of the good stuff!

    • By Filmalaska
      Howdy,
      Can anyone recommend where to buy a headphone adapter for Minelab’s proprietary headphone jack?
      thanks,
      Morgan

    • By phrunt
      A package I've been very much looking forward to arrived in the mail today, I call them the twins.  It made sense to package them both in one package for postage reasons and fortunately JW was working doing some renovations at his house around the corner from mine today so he had his a few minutes after the courier arrived at my place with the package as I shot straight over to give it to him. 
      I tore the box open to find them extremely well packaged


      And now the twins

      15x10 spiral wound X-coils, one for the GPZ, one for the GPX.  The GPZ's coils curly cord seems good to me.

      They came with a spare coil cover.  This is obviously the GPZ coil.

      And the GPX one.
      Hopefully I can find some gold soon with it, I've on a dry spell at the moment, although the football field of coins has kept me busy.  It's been about a month since I've attempted to find gold as my weekends are filled with skiing as my daughter is addicted to it and my week days have been busy doing the local coin hunting, now this coil has arrived I best get out there soon.  It snowed yesterday and today there is a freezing wind blowing off the snow, if it wasn't for that I'd be shooting off now to test it out.  Only about 2 weeks left of ski season.
      JW's been doing pretty well lately with his 10x9" X-coil and he rarely takes it off he loves it so much so it will be interesting to see how he goes with this new one being spiral (flat wound) when his 10x9" is bundle wound. 
    • By WesD
      I saw some of the guys in Australia make a Trumpet to deflect the sound upward from the speaker on the sdc. Great idea, but shipping was a bit much, so I cut a 90 pcv fitting in half and used velcroe to attach.  Cheap little project and does add a noticeable increase in sound coming up from the speaker.

×
×
  • Create New...