Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
mh9162013

Using A Garrett Pro-Pointer AT ( Carrot ) Without A 9v Battery

Recommended Posts

A while ago, I posted about a using a Minelab Pro-Find 35 without a 9V battery. You can read more about it here: 

But I wanted to run the modification with NiMH batteries. However, due to space constraints in the Pro-Find, this was not possible without modifying the internal battery compartment (which I didn't want to do b/c it would void the warranty, I'm sure). So instead, the Pro-Find runs off of a LiPo cell.

Well, I got a hold of a Garrett Carrot (Pro-Pointer AT) and given the extra space for the battery, I was able to run the 9V booster off of 3 LSD NiMH AAA cells. Works like a charm! The advantage is that I don't have to worry about "babying" the LiPo cell and worry about storing it with too little charge or anything like that.

Not much else to say, except show you the pictures.

 

 

 

20191016_133006.jpg

20191016_133018.jpg

20191016_133021.jpg

20191016_133033.jpg

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting mission, and you did follow through with what you said you wanted to do, that's dedication 🙂

What's the battery life like and is it comparable to the 9v? Have you compared the difference in performance between the 1.5 volt mod and the original 9v battery with depth on targets and so on?  It should be similar but I've found using a 9.6v Powerex battery appears to give my Carrot better performance than using a standard 9v rechargeable, maybe it's a placebo but I feel it goes deeper using them.

Did you use a boost regulator like this in it? https://www.pololu.com/product/791

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you'll find it's the Placebo effect, Simon. The beeper and vibe motor are likely to be driven 'directly' from the 9 volt supply, and not from a regulated 5 volt rail, so it's going to beep louder and shake more with one of those batteries, maybe fooling you. I've not seen any reverse-engineering on the 'carrot', only the original model. But in that, nearly everything is powered from a 5 volt linear regulated supply. So you would be better off with a 7-cell "8.4V" NiMH battery, as they have a greater capacity than the 8-cell "9.6V" type.

I'm also curious as to which specific boost regulator was used. Pointers take a hefty current draw when vibe-motor / beeper activate, eg. the turn-on routine. I imagine many of these modules would keel over as soon as you switched on the pointer.
It seems odd that you have no power switch between the NiMH cells and the boost regulator. Isn't this going to flatten the battery, even with the pointer turned off ?

I've played around with similar modules for driving high-power LED's. I have some GU10 5 watt lights, that are 5 x 1 Watt LED's in series, so would need about 16 volts to drive them. I used a boost regulator module, modified for current feedback, so it regulates the output at 280mA. Input power is likely to be two 18650 Li cells in series ( laptop battery salvages ).
I had some similar cunning plans to re-use some LED backlight strips from a defunct LCD television.

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Phrunt,

This is the voltage booster I'm using: https://www.pololu.com/product/2116

As for battery life, I haven't done real world testing, because there's no point given how I'm not able to metal detect as often as I'd like and how inconsistent and qualitative the observations would be. I could create some sort of "lab" set up to measure how long the pinpointer beeps and vibrates or something, but I'm not going to waste my time with that because using simple math should give a good enough ballpark estimate, which I predict will be about 50-60% of the run time you would get with an alkaline battery. I discuss how I get this number in my blog post concerning this set up in a Minelab Pro-Find 35. That LiPo cell has roughly the same capacity as these AAA NiMH cells. In that blog post I also mentioned a very slight performance increase in sensitivity (about 1-3 mm of extra range).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, PimentoUK said:

...

I'm also curious as to which specific boost regulator was used. Pointers take a hefty current draw when vibe-motor / beeper activate, eg. the turn-on routine. I imagine many of these modules would keel over as soon as you switched on the pointer.
It seems odd that you have no power switch between the NiMH cells and the boost regulator. Isn't this going to flatten the battery, even with the pointer turned off ?

...

I'm not worried about current draw; the voltage booster I'm using can provide up to 1.4 amps, well in excess of what a standard 9V alkaline can reasonably provide.

And no, I have no power switch between the NiMH cells and the booster. Do I need one? Maybe. I'm letting my setup sit in my Garrett Carrot right now and I'll test it every few days to see how long it "lasts" in storage before I need to recharge the battery pack. Assuming the booster draws noticeable current, a switch would be useful, but I doubt it'll be worth the trouble as it would just be easier to unplug the battery pack from the booster if I was going to store my pinpointer for an extended period of time. I may also look for some smaller high efficiency battery plugs, too...

And don't forget, even if my setup has plenty of drawbacks, it still has a HUGE advantage: NO MORE 9V BATTERIES!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's a shame it's pretty tricky to modify the pointer so the power switch controls the boost regulator input. You would have to remove the switch from the PCB, then re-fit it on its own isolated board. This would then require the button shaft to be trimmed in length, due to the height increase. It would be easier to do on the original black propointer.

I don't share your dislike of 9V batteries in quite the same way. I don't like NiMH 9V's in high-drain applications, like pinpointers. The cells are rather small, and the heavy current draw causes problems, usually high internal resistance failure. And with 7 cells in series, they have poor reliability and life, as when one cell fails, so does the whole battery, of course.

I'm looking at Lithium 9V batteries at the moment ( for pinpointer use ), the EBL ones specifically. They only have two cells, and they are pretty large cells, so they can easily handle the power requirements.

What is intriguing is how they are charged. Only the two main terminals are brought out, there's no obvious 'hidden' third terminal ( for the internal connection of the cells ). Yet they can be charged at 600 mA in the dedicated charger. There must be some 'clever electronics' inside the battery, to take care of charge-balancing somehow.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Would you recommend this over my 9.6v batteries?

521282732.jpg

I do like this brand, they're solid performers and what they say they are is what they are.  I've been using them for a couple of years now and my original battery seems to work as well now as it did when I first got it.  I've only got the 9.6v versions though.

You may well be right the performance difference might be a placebo and the difference I'm noticing is with volume/more vibration which would make the Carrot feel more powerful. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not so much 'recommend', you already have the 9.6V ones, so there's no point changing or buying more. It's just that the 9.6V ones don't offer any obvious advantage in a pinpointer. You probably take the battery out and recharge it after nearly every session anyway, so it never gets near flat, and so the lower capacity is not relevant.
I usually carry a spare 9V with me, in case the one in the pointer dies [or I leave it at home in the charger ..]. My spare is typically an alkaline non-rechargeable, due to the shelf life.

( and I recharge my non-rechargeable 9V batteries too. If you do it with a low current, it seems to work )

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, PimentoUK said:

...
I don't share your dislike of 9V batteries in quite the same way. I don't like NiMH 9V's in high-drain applications, like pinpointers. The cells are rather small, and the heavy current draw causes problems, usually high internal resistance failure. And with 7 cells in series, they have poor reliability and life, as when one cell fails, so does the whole battery, of course.

...

A NiMH 9V battery? No thank you. The solution to getting rid of heavy duty or alkaline 9V batteries isn't to replace it with a NiMH 9V battery. It's to get rid of the 9V battery.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, PimentoUK said:

...
( and I recharge my non-rechargeable 9V batteries too. If you do it with a low current, it seems to work )

What?!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Robertson14
      My pro find 35 keeps beeping when I change the sensitivity to higher. Is this normal?
    • By Ridge Runner
      I myself don’t see the advantage of a folding handle but I guess it makes it more compact.
       Chuck 

    • By 1515Art
      it seems the biggest weakness of the GPZ is the lack of any reliable discrimination other than a best guess as to depth due to the double target response. My Whites SST will power up in seconds and is a great detector with excellent iron discrimination and may even give an accurate iron response in proximity to the GPZ, but its not practical to carry both. my question is there a small lightweight detector that would compliment the GPZ mainly by giving the operator a second look that reads for an iron signal on the target in question, something like a pin pointer with some decent depth made for iron.
    • By Hobo
      Has anyone tried using a Sunray probe for small nugget hunting? It seems to me that a sunray probe attatched to shaft of a GB Pro or a F75 would work great in places where a larger coil would be too big, like in cracks and around rocks. Since the Sunray workes off of the detectors control box it should have good depth and sensitivity.
    • By Oiwon
      After much deliberation I finally pulled the trigger on the Nokta/Makro pulse dive. My old pp crapped out and this seemed like a logical choice for me because A: it's a waterproof pinpointer and B: it doubles as an underwater hand-held detector. I've constantly been gathering feedback online about this machine as it had sparked my curiosity from the first glance. It arrived Wed in a nice heavy duty carrying case. The case isn't something I would lug around, but it is perfect for garage/closet storage. (or just a cool decoration on my cabinet)
      Taking into consideration the carrying case, the versatility, the pp coil-cover and the waterproofness it seemed like a good bargain, and I must say, 160 bucks and a few days later I still feel that way. 
      It definitely doesn't feel like a toy.. (but it's as fun as one) You can tell some thought went in to this thing when you pick it up and start pushing buttons and connecting and disconnecting things. No it doesn't have the depth that a nox or a fisher has, but having had one, I believe it exceeds the depth of a garrett carrot. What do you expect? It's a smaller handheld device. I have to admit that what i saw from the air tests, and lack of air tests online left me feeling underwhelmed and hesitant, however since powering it up the first time I have been pleasantly surprised by its responsiveness. I have tested it on several gold and silver pieces of jewelry we have here and it was able to pick them all up. No this isn't a fine tooth comb, and perhaps there are things it will miss, but it also doesn't discriminate - i mean you can come up with a hundred things it's not, and it wont do. Let me tell you what it has done for me so far. It has solved my lack of a pinpointer problem. It has made my underwater searching way easier and allowed me to cover more ground and recover targets faster. I no longer have to lug around my nox in the rolling waves if I don't want to. I can easily swing my arm around under water while i kneel, crawl, float, lay on my belly, or swim around.
      Maybe I hit the jackpot when I took it to the beach today and 5 minutes into my first hunt, found my first target, a beautiful diamond or diamond-ish ring. (GF already stole it from me - see pics below.) 
      It was about 3 - 4 inches below the sand under about 3 feet of water. 
      Most fun i've had detecting in a long time. Not an excal. Not a sandshark. Just a fun way to search for stuff while you swim. Now I have only taken it out once and plan to add some more updates as i continue use in the future but wanted to share this with the community for those who might be interested and those who may be on the fence. In my opinion if you are considering spending $100+ on a PP why not get something with a bit more utility? Especially if you mess around in the wet water stuff like i do. 
      Seems durable. Nice weight to it. The vibrate function and sound works very well. The coil attachments are very easy to take on and off. It also came with a lanyard that i conveniently hooped around my wrist. Just dont forget to put the waterproof cap back on the bottom after charging - before you leave the house and walk to the beach, otherwise you will have to walk all the way back to the house to get it and then walk all the way back to the beach again. Anyways, i had a blast and I cant wait to take it for another spin. Don't really understand all the negative feedback i've seen online, though it's still early. If you are considering getting one and your expectations are realistic, i think you will be pleasantly surprised. The lil lady says she wants to get one as well. 
      I can't really speak about how it compares to the Quest handheld or other similar style detectors because I haven't used them. Also i am not affiliated with this company nor any other company.
      Cheers and HH all


    • By Hard Prospector
      Looking to get a new pin pointer (to assist in nugget shooting) as mine is 7 years old. There must be better more sensitive ones available these days. Input would be much appreciated......Thanks!
×
×
  • Create New...