Jump to content
Chase Goldman

Why The Simplex Is More Compelling To Me Than Vanquish - Performance Diversity

Recommended Posts

I am not really looking for a new detector to add to my arsenal.  I think my Deus, Equinox, and GPX cover the bases pretty well.  I keep an MXT and F75 DST around mainly for nostalgic reasons (like a guitarist collects guitars) and because they were classic designs in their day with solid performance, features, design, and ergonomics bar none in the case of the F75.  I laso keep my Tek Delta around because it was the detector with which I really learned how to detect and helped me form a passion for the hobby.  Plus they all support concentric coils which are advantageous under certain conditions.

So why was I still drawn to the two new low cost offerings by Makro and Minelab? There is always something refreshing about a stripped down, back to basics detector design that incorporates the latest tech and capabilities (e.g., Multi IQ for Vanquish, straight forward single frequency detecting with decent all metal capability, and a waterproof package for the Simplex).

Why get another detector, when my main arsenal seemingly consists of detectors that should easily outperform either Vanquish or Simplex?

The answer is simple, performance diversity.  Hitting a site with a different detectors of diverse capabilities, features, performance usually pays of if you have the luxury of time and access.  Last week, at several different types of CW relic sites in Virginia I was able to use the diverse capabilities of the three detectors I mentioned in the second sentence of my post and each delivered with keeper finds under the conditions to which they typically excel.  The GPX penetrated deep into highly mineralized soils of those Virginia fields to snag a number of deep non-ferrous brass and lead targets including my first US Cavalry bit boss - a "bucket lister" for me.  The Equinox with its Multi IQ capabilities and diverse modes (including gold mode) was able to ID and lock onto shallower no-ferrous targets in the mineralized muck of multiple non-ferrous and ferrous targets which enabled me to ultimately pull several non-ferrous keepers out of a single hole.  And the Deus gave my tired arm a break while deftly navigating between huge chunks of big iron in pitch mode that enabled me to literally visualize the large target footprint of these big iron targets and as a result snagged some actual ferrous CW relics including stove leg and some antique door hinges and other unique ferrous keepers.

So what does this have to do with Vanquish and Simplex?

The Vanquish is a very capable entry level detector with some high-end features (Multi IQ) and a cool coil selection and neat stem design but, not surprisingly, very limited setting customization options and missing features that appropriately put in a couple of notches below the even the Equinox 600.  Some of the missing features are quite frankly head scratching as far as I am concerned (e.g., not fully waterproof housing, lack of user firmware update capability, no single frequency mode option, and while the coil selection is compelling, those coils are not also compatible with Equinox - a missed opportunity IMO - confirmed with me in person by Debbie S of Minelab at last week's dig).  Sometimes manufacturers tease higher end features into their new lower-end offerings that are otherwise not available in their mid or high level offerings.  Other than the decent coil selection, there is no such situation here.  The Equinox envelopes the Vanquish completely.  Bottom line, the Vanquish is solid and provides "multifrequency for the masses" but brings nothing to the table for Equinox users.  That is not slam, it is a fact and frankly is not unexpected.  If the coils were cross compatible with Equinox, I might seriously consider picking up a Vanquish solely for the opportunity to use the coils on Equinox while getting a fairly decent emergency backup or grab n go machine in the process.  But with the coils solely married to the less capable Vanquish and without the capability to wring the most out of them, it is a pass for me.

The Simplex on the other hand is limited to single frequency and the emphasis is on solid basic performance and ease of use.  Yet Nokta has packed it with some high end features such as fully waterproof, wireless ready (and cheaper than the wireless variant of the Vanquish), firmware updates (updates and bug fixes have already been released), and the promise of some decent accessory coils consistent with the Nokta track record on their other recent detector designs.  So there are slight feature advantages that in the Simplex design that provide something a little more compelling in the "basics" than Vanquish, though Vanquish does have Multi IQ going for it.  

Since I do not own a Nokta or Makro detector, the Simplex provides the performance diversity that the Vanquish does not, IN MY CASE.  This would not necessarily be true of those who might own a Kruzer, Anfibio or Impact.  For those folks, the Simplex probably looks to them the same way the Vanquish looks to me or the typical Equinox owner.  At this price point, the performance diversity is worth it.  I get Nokta's signal processing which is lacking in my arsenal, a decent VCO all metal mode (which I prefer over the processed discrete tones of the Equinox in the non-gold modes) and the prospect of decent accessory coil choices with user upgrade-able firmware in a waterproof package.  It is still entry level and fairly basic, but compelling to me from a performance diversity standpoint, nevertheless.

Remember, this is only my opinion and is applicable to my particular situation based on the detectors I already own and the type of detecting I like to do (primarily CW and Colonial relic hunting).  It should not be misconstrued as Simplex is better than Vanquish or that these detectors can outperform their more expensive and capable cousins.  

So do you find either the Simplex and/or Vanquish compelling even if you do own higher end detectors already?  Discuss your thoughts below.

 

 

nokta-makro-simplex-underwater-wireless-metal-detector.jpg

  • Like 9

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have mild curiosity, same as whenever a new detector is released. Entry level detectors have really improved since I first started with an Ace 250 in 2011.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is true there is no clear winner in this race, Multi-IQ is the massive draw card to the Vanquish for me personally.  I promised myself I'd never buy another single frequency detector, the days of single frequency are numbered in my opinion but it's so hard to resist.  It's after all old outdated technology and with Nokta working on multi frequency who knows in a couple of years other brands may have it too and then we'll likely be putting all our old single frequency detectors in the cupboard.

For most of us it probably makes sense not to buy either as we already have superior detectors, but that's just so difficult to do 🙂

Nobody is right or wrong with either of them, if you hunt fresh water the Simplex is a clear winner, are you going to take that Simplex to the beach and jump in and start detecting in the salt water with it? Not very likely.  You're not going to be able to do that with the Vanquish either but you'll be able to get that coil down in the salt water and do some good beach hunting.

The Vanquish with the v8 coil (Pro Pack) may end up being the cheapest small gold detector on the market with multi-IQ and all metal mode, something I look forward to testing.

It really comes down to what you want to use the detector for.....

The best thing about both of these detectors is they've set a new benchmark in price and performance.  It's put other manufacturers on notice, they can no longer charge what they used to.... First Texas appears to be seeing this making the F19 (better version of the Gold Bug Pro) into a Bounty Hunter.

 

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Chase Goldman said:

(Simplex provides) Nokta's signal processing which is lacking in my arsenal, a decent VCO all metal mode (which I prefer over the processed discrete tones of the Equinox in the non-gold modes) and the prospect of decent accessory coil choices with user upgrade-able firmware in a waterproof package.

 

1 hour ago, phrunt said:

The Vanquish with the v8 coil (Pro Pack) may end up being the cheapest small gold detector on the market with multi-IQ and all metal mode....

I think we're again at the mercy (nice way of putting it?) of different manufacturers' usage of the term 'all metal'.  Minelab has chosen to mean discriminate mode (and its associated filtering) with all segments open (i.e. no discrimination threshold and no notching).  Simplex goes with the industry standard (first one's to the plate) meaning, what Dave Johnson expands here:  (http://www.fisherlab.com/hobby/davejohnson/goldprospectingmetaldetectiontechnologies.htm

Most VLF prospecting is done in an all-metals mode which may be variously described as "single-filter", "first derivative", "autotune", or by trademarked names.

 

 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's true, but it makes no difference in terms of results, I've found 0.011 gram (0.169 of a grain) bits of gold with the Equinox 800 in "all metal mode", quite a few that size so it wasn't just fluke 🙂

I have all confidence in the Equinox all metal mode in multi-IQ, so I am assuming the Vanquish one will be just the same, and if it is I'm happy.  I'm especially interested in the V8 8x5" DD coil, a coil I truly wish was made for the Equinox.

1382344998_v8coil.jpg.c050953d7221d09010ea982fd635d95f.jpg

I really like that coil 🙂  I'm not worried it's not solid, the holes are going to be pretty small. I'd rather a pointy noise on it though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No more VLF for me unless it’s a clearly superior replacement for my Equinox. I’ve been thinking about the ORX and Simplex but just keep telling myself no, I have the Equinox, I don't actually need them. The old battle of separating needs from wants! :smile: It’s the way they are packaged as much as what they can do that makes me want them but they will not do anything I can't already do with my Equinox. I suspect my next detector will be the Fisher Impulse AQ, assuming that they ever actually release it. I'm lacking a waterproof beach PI so that I actually have a need for.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well Steve, the Orx is an amazing detector. Orx w/ 9" coil is better in iron than the Equinox w/ 11" coil. I would say equal with Equinox using 6" coil.

Will not be get rid of either. I also have the waterproof kit for the Orx too. The Orx doesn't false like the Equinox in iron.

To bad the coils cost so much for the Orx.

Looking forward to seeing the Fisher AQ too.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Since I only have 2 detectors my 800 and a old Bounty Hunter, I can only say I wish I had known about this forum before I got my 800.

Not that I don't like the 800 of which I do, but to have helped me learn more on what to have purchased in the first place.

I have learned so much here and every time I am out I learn even more.

Once I learn how to use this properly and know what I am hearing I will be looking for an other unit.

I try to learn something everything and the hardest thing for me is that I constantly have ringing in the ears which throws me off a lot.

Thank you Steve for all your insight on all detector units that you talk about. I also thank everyone else for their knowledge on this subject also as I am a beginner at this.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, 2Valen said:

Once I learn how to use this properly and know what I am hearing I will be looking for an other unit.

Unless there is a big change in VLF technology or you want to get serious about prospecting there is really no need to get another unit, you're up there with the best and you've got a true multi purpose detector, perhaps another coil for it might be a wiser choice if you've only got the stock coil?  Some of us buy lots of detectors as we like the technology and playing with it, it's a big waste of money 🙂 , I'm very guilty of that however when hunts get serious out comes the Nox.

If you are into prospecting then yes, a PI of some form would be a wise future investment.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, phrunt said:

there is really no need to get another unit

Simon.

Thanks for the advice, and I only have the stock coil that came with it. I might get another coil in the spring and work with it.

I am still trying to figure out if something is wrong with my unit as it has done several things that is unusual.

Like I have said I am learning from all of you here on this forum and I try to put that knowledge to use. I do get confused sometimes wit all that I need to do , but that is expected with only 3-4 months of use.

Thanks for the advice and I will keep it in mind.

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Steve Herschbach
      Getting Started With The Vanquish 440/540 Version 4901-0304-4
      Minelab Vanquish 440/540 Getting Started Guide
      Minelab Vanquish Color Brochure

      Minelab Vanquish 440/540 Quick Start Guide
       
    • By Steve Herschbach
      Minelab Vanquish 440/540 User Manual Version 4901-0305-2
      Minelab Vanquish 440/540 Instruction Manual
      Minelab Vanquish 340 Instruction Manual
      Minelab Vanquish Color Brochure

    • By Steve Herschbach
      I have been lobbying for a mid-range elliptical coil for the Equinox for two years now, since it is the kind of coil lots of gold prospectors like to use. Minelab throws my suggestions in the trash bin when it comes to coils unfortunately. 
      Then the light bulb went off. The stock 11" coil for the Equinox sells for $229. I can get a 7" x 10" Multi-IQ coil for only $199 and a free metal detector to run it! It's called the Vanquish 340.
      No, Vanquish coils will not work on the Equinox. That would make too much sense. But still, $199 for a coil with a free detector included is a pretty hard deal to beat, don't you think?  I was kind of blowing Vanquish off but now I'm actually thinking a 340 might be a fun little machine to have around. It has to be sweet on the arm at 2.6 lbs with an S rod.
      Just a thought.

      Minelab Vanquish 340 metal detector
      Search Modes - Coin, Jewelry, All Metal
      Custom User Search Profile - No
      Operating Frequencies (kHz) - Multi-IQ
      Noise Cancel - Auto (19 Channels)
      Bluetooth Audio - No
      Iron Bias - High
      Sensitivity - 4 levels
      Volume - 3 levels
      Target Tones - 3 tones (Low, Mid, High)
      Discrimination Segments - 5 segments
      Target ID's - -9 to 40
      Depth Indicator - 4 levels
      Length - Extended: 1450 mm (57") Collapsed: 760 mm (30")
      Weight (incl. batteries) - 2.6 lbs (1.2 kg)
      Standard Coil - V10 10" x 7" Double-D
      Audio Output - In-built loudspeaker, 3.5 mm (1/8") jack
      Supplied Headphones - None
      Display - Monochrome LCD
      Supplied Batteries - 4 x AA Alkaline replaceable
      Waterproof - Coil to 1 meter/3 feet
      Operating Temperature Range -  -10°C to +40°C (+14°F to +104°F)
      Storage Temperature Range -  -20°C to +70°C (-4°F to +158°F)
      Key Technologies - Multi-IQ
      Minelab Vanquish 340 Instruction Manual
      Forum threads with "vanquish" tag

      Minelab Vanquish 340 display and controls
       
    • By wltdwiz
      hi all
      just got me a simplex & gotta tell you they named it right
      its a simple to run hi teck detector with lots of features & its got some bite to it..
      took it down the what i call the beach from hell  lots of bottle caps & nails & hot Arizona ground
      ground balanced at 87 & ran it in park..
      i would love to tell you that it dident pick up bottle caps but its a dd coil so it hits them but up just bellow the zinc penny range they could be dealt with hope they get a concentric out soon..
      the simplex has a wide spread on the discrimination nickles 22-23 coins 79-90 pulltabs in the middle.. hits hard on nickles..
      she found me this little beauty on a heavily worked beach in a mass of iron .. rang in at 19-20
      10 k 2.3 grams
      im happy  i have a new friend..
      Thanks makro for a great detector

    • By Steve Herschbach
      Beach Hunter Dec 3, 2019 - Minelab Vanquish Beach Review Finds Silver
       
    • By Steve Herschbach
      Complete tear down with good circuit board photos here.

×
×
  • Create New...