Jump to content
Doc

Doc's Saga™ Epic Fail - Back To The Drawing Board

Recommended Posts

Hey Gang,

Well, back to the drawing board.  The first samples of Swing Arms we got into the field have failed miserably.  Thanks to all of you who have put up with the frustration of being guinea pigs.  If you have had one that failed, return to the dealer and he will refund your money, until the revised version is available.

If you have one that has not failed, use it until it does, so you can give us feedback on what happened.  Pictures are very helpful. So some of the things that have been identified are:

1.  The strap, which I requested be made with some kind of UV rubber with fiber reinforcement was not made with reinforcement, so it stretches and then breaks.  It also needs to be about  1 1/2 inches longer with one more adjustment hole.

2.  The pivot ball joint has way too much play in it.  It should only rotate 360 degrees with no side to side movement.  Initially I thought it would give more freedom of movement, but it is movement that is not necessary and causes undo stress on the joint and a feeling of instability.  The purpose of the ball joint is to only allow the arm to move up and down so it does not break.  But the opposite is happening, because it has so much movement, there is a lot of stress on the part.  That is an easy fix, the collar has to be redesigned to restrict the movement.  I'll try to attach a pdf file to show you what I am talking about.

Collar correction.pdf

3.  The pivot joint, the one that has a pin in it that allows the Swing Arm to swing out and away from the detector is too thin and flimsy.  This was supposed to be made of Nyglass, but I think they used something that was not suitable for this part.  This will have to be redesigned to be thicker with tougher material and a more substantial nylon pin that will be sonic welded into place.

The concept and functionality is solid, it is just the materials and some of the design that needs to be corrected.

Now I don't know many manufacturers that announce to the public that they "screwed the pooch" so to speak.  But you guys have always been very helpful with ideas and suggestions and helping me field test all this crazy stuff I come up with.  So I wanted to include you on this.  And trust me, this is the process I go through every time with everything I develop.  From initial concept, to design to prototype to pre-production to testing to modification and back to testing and then to full production and shipping and delivery and to the market runs about 9 months to 1 year.  Sometimes things go very smoothly, sometimes, not so much.  It depends on the complexity of the item.  Unfortunately for this SAGA swing arm there are so many different molded moving parts.  2 Molds for the handle, a mold for the storage clip, 3 molds for the pivot and pivot ball joint assembly, 1 mold for the straps, a mold for the buttons in the fiberglass rod, extrusion mold for the fiberglass rods.  About $10,000 in mold costs alone.  Fun, right?

However, I have never brought to market anything that I don't use myself and stand behind 100%  And the SAGA Swing Assist Guide Arm will be no different.  So your patience is appreciated as we work on SAGA™ Version 2.0

Speaking of production, the "G Spot" scoops are in production but I had them made with a satin finish as in the attached picture.  The shiny ABS material caused too much glare in my opinion and was too slick allowing small gold to slide too easily.  The top picture is the new satin finish and the bottom scoop was the shiny prototype.


G Spot matte finish sml.jpg

Standby while we work out the bugs.  Thank you and Happy New Year.
Doc

  • Like 7
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Love your honesty Doc  👍

The issue may also be the name - it was always going to be a long, drawn out SAGA with a name like that  😉

Best wishes with the fixes and amendments - hopefully not too lengthy or costly. 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Northeast said:

Love your honesty Doc  👍

The issue may also be the name - it was always going to be a long, drawn out SAGA with a name like that  😉

Best wishes with the fixes and amendments - hopefully not too lengthy or costly. 

I may have jinxed myself with a name like that.  But it was shorter than Swing Assist Guide Arm.  One of the definitions of Saga is "a long story of heroic achievement."  Hopefully it will be that kind of Saga.  Not the kind of long story where I sit defeated in a corner and cry. 🤣

Doc

  • Like 1
  • Haha 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally, I favor the more information option you have exhibited, vs no info.  That policy eliminates speculations and maintains your “golden” reputation.

I’ll be buying ASAP when the dust has settled.  Thank you for your trying to bring great product upgrades. 
What is appreciated is that you are sticking to your business ethics as you’ve always done.

Keep us posted, and thanks.  Dave

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Steve Herschbach
      It has been common knowledge among those paying attention that Nokta/Makro has been working on a new simultaneous multifrequency detector for some time now. The Simplex+ has been specifically stated as being the potential housing for the new unit when it appears. This post from 2/17/2020 reconfirms work on the new model:
      "Hello all... yes, the name has been chosen and the machine is in the works. Cannot confirm the release date as of today but hopefully I will be able to share more info further into the year. Hope this helps...."
      People often bring up patents as a reason why new multifrequency units have been so rare to appear, but the fact is patents on machines like the 5 & 15 kHz Fisher CZ, White's 3 & 15 kHz DFX, and Minelab BBS (billed as 17 transmitted but more likely 2 - 3 processed frequencies out of 17 transmitted) have all expired. Nokta/Makro has plenty to work with.
      Given the speed with which Nokta/Makro has brought new machines to market in the past and the fact they have a mostly proven housing in hand now via the Simplex, I expect an announcement by this fall with a detector available either before Christmas or next spring. If I was them right now I would be collecting warranty claim info to make sure the Simplex housing is bullet proof before launching the new unit, and that should be going well by now. In the meantime work can proceed on design and testing of the circuit.
      Frankly, there is no need to do anything radical to be successful. If Nokta/Makro simply did what Fisher should have done years ago and mage a digital clone of the CZ but with target id instead of meter, put in a waterproof Simplex box with wireless, and at their normal great pricing, they will have a winner. Many people would kill for a Excalibur BBS clone in a Simplex style housing. The main thing multifrequency offers is good VLF saltwater performance, and a Nokta/Makro Multiplex (my guess ) model would be an easy sale for a lot of beach hunters plus the general coin, relic, jewelry market.
      There will probably not be any real news for some time but when I hear anything, this is the thread I will post on.

      Nokta/Makro Multifrequency metal detector?
    • By Steve Herschbach
      With 2019 in the rear view mirror what will 2020 bring? Multi Frequency? Pulse Induction? One thing is for sure, this company is going places fast!
       
    • By Steve Herschbach
      From the Prescott Daily Courier http://www.prescottaz.com/m/Articles.aspx?ArticleID=140625 
      Jack Delano Gifford, 75, passed away Jan. 3, 2015. He was born in Miami, Arizona, the son of Norval and Mayme Gifford. When Jack was about 6 years old, he and his family moved to the Phoenix area, and he lived there until he moved to Prescott, Arizona.
      After high school, Jack served his country in the National Guard for six years. During that time, he also earned a technical degree in electronics and started a family. In his early electronics career, he worked in the aerospace industry. During a slowdown in the '70s, he was recruited by a metal detector company and worked in that industry until his retirement. Jack was an entrepreneur and an electronics design engineer, and founded three companies. The last one, Tesoro Electronics, brought him many friends and national and international acclaim for his designs and his support of the industry. He started that company in Glendale, Arizona, in 1980 and when he moved it to Prescott in 1991, it provided new technical jobs and industry for this area.
      Jack started visiting Prescott when he was in high school and, during his careers, he and Myrna would visit the area for some much needed R & R. Eventually he realized he could move the company to Prescott so they could enjoy the Prescott lifestyle full-time.
      Jack loved his family, motorcycles, metal-detecting and working on vintage stereo equipment. He also built the speakers to complete the systems, many of which he gave to family and friends. After retirement, he became a PADI-certified scuba-diver. Jack joined American Lutheran Church and served on their board. He was part of the Tuesday night men's Bible study and worked in ALC's outreach programs such as The Rock and Teen Closet. He also worked at the Prescott Community Cupboard Food Bank and served on their board.
      Jack is survived by his wife of 54 years, Myrna; sons James and Vince (Katy); three amazing granddaughters, Isabella, Lily and Charlotte; sister Gloria Gray; and many nephews and nieces. He was predeceased by his parents, infant daughter Kelly Jeanine, and sister Glenna.
    • By Steve Herschbach
      From the Codan news release at http://www.codan.com.au/Portals/0/investorpubs/22 AXS Announcement - Minelab awarded $6.7m contract.pdf (copy below):
      "Cooperating with NIITEK Inc., the HDD will combine Minelab’s new Multiple Frequency Continuous Wave metal detection technology and NIITEK’s advanced ground penetrating radar."
       
      31 August 2016
      MINELAB AWARDED CONTRACT TO DEVELOP NEW HANDHELD DEVICE DETECTOR FOR THE AUSTRALIAN DEFENCE FORCE
      Minelab Electronics, a wholly owned subsidiary of Codan Limited, has been awarded a $6.7m contract by the Department of Defence to develop a new Handheld Device Detector (HDD). The funding received under this contract is to further develop a dual sensor metal detector which incorporates ground penetrating radar. It will partially offset the development costs of the product, and the project is expected to be completed by 2018.
      The development of the HDD builds on Minelab's success in technology development and product innovation for use in military programmes.
      Codan is particularly pleased to be of service to the ADF and to provide an enhanced capability that currently does not exist. Once the HDD enters into service with the ADF, we are confident that other militaries will seek the same level of capability, broadening our market for countermine products.
      The contract supports Codan's stated strategy of growing its profitability by improving and broadening our product offerings while ensuring our value propositions remain relevant and leading-edge.
      Previous to this award, in March 2014, Minelab was selected by the Department of Defence's Rapid Prototype Development and Evaluation (RPDE) programme to receive
      $1.0m in funding to further integrate metal detection and ground penetration radar technologies into a lightweight and compact mechanical platform. In December 2014, RPDE provided an additional $1.3m in funding, and Minelab subsequently produced an advanced prototype of the HDD.
      Cooperating with NIITEK Inc., the HDD will combine Minelab's new Multiple Frequency Continuous Wave metal detection technology and NIITEK's advanced ground penetrating radar. The HDD was designed taking into account the comprehensive requirements of the ADF, supplemented with feedback from Army User Groups. It will include advanced detection technologies as well as new standards of compactness and ergonomics.
      On behalf of the Board
      Michael Barton Company Secretary
      MORE INFORMATION ON THE NIITEK/MINELAB GROUNDSHARK
      Minelab Mineshark


    • By Ridge Runner
      I was gone part of the morning but when I got home it was a pleasant surprise at my door.
       My I believe new Simplex was waiting for me. It came on a two day priority mail that I believe that Dilek had something to do with. It came back double boxed like I sent it .
       Life is great when you’re dealing with great people and a great company. You know up front who you want to spend your money with.
       Dilek I sent you a personal message but let me say it again. Thank you so much !
       Chuck 
×
×
  • Create New...