Jump to content

Stone Id: Are These Limestones?

Recommended Posts

Hello guys. I'm setting up a 50 gallon aquarium that reflect the local landscape (I live in the UAE, where there are tons of limestones and granites along the hajjar mountains, from my understanding these are mostly sedimentary rocks). I've found a few good stones here (in the pic) in my last hiking trip.


In the vinegar (6% acid) test on them, there was some fizz but only minor and in corrosive areas. There is a common talk among aquarium folks that limestones leach heavy metals and alter PH/Hardness of the water. These usually come from people who aren't really geologists - I was looking for some reliable info on how likely the water (my tap water ph is 7.6-7.8, water hardness 4.0 dgH, carbonate hardness 4.0 dkH) will undergo changes? I do understand it may happen given the aqaurium water ph can fluctuate slightly but shouldn't this take a very, very long time? I would highly appreciate any expert advice on this.

Link to post
Share on other sites

It does not take long at all for limestone to alter the ph of an aquarium as it's reactive to any acids in the tank.  Think fish urine.  Small lime stones dont tend to cause a problem but large amounts can make ph control impossible and that often leads to sever problems with biologic s~ fungus, algae and some parasites.  This is why aquarium owners avoid lime stone.  You'll be better served with quartz, hard granites and some schists if you want to decorate.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, DDancer said:

This is why aquarium owners avoid lime stone. 

You are so correct about that and it can also kill some fish in a tank. I have always stayed away from anything limestone in my tanks.

Link to post
Share on other sites

If in doubt dont,i have kept fish for over 50+ years and if i have had any doubts and it may harm any of the fish then its not used how ever pretty the rocks are.


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Similar Content

    • By Rick N. MI
      Found this brass tire stem and cap down deep. I don't know what it is off of or how old it could be. Strange it was in the water.

    • By Carol Reynolds
      Can any of you tell me what this is?  A gift from my father when I was young.  He traveled all over the world so his location does not help.  It is about the size of a large hand.

    • By Johny
      Meteorite or rock?

      Found this today kind of looks like possibly a Chromite meteorite but not sure so hoping some one could help. Browsed some pictures of
      small Chromite meteorites on google images and seen some similar.

      Dimension is about 1.5" diameter and about 40 grams heavy.
      Not magnetic checked with magnet and my Garrett Pro-Pointer II detects nothing
      Found in London, Ontario, Canada

      Any help would be great

    • By Maria
      Can you tell me what it is? I found this in Central Florida and the only "rocks" we have here are fossilized corals. But it was near the "landscaping rocks" pile people in FL buy and litter their property with, so it could be part of this pile and in that case brought from out of state. It is very heavy and feels solid. 2 corners are chipped and some different yellow material shows through. 
      Thank you for suggestions. 
    • By Kit426
      Are these diamonds? 
      And/or possibly a piece of a meteorites?

  • Create New...