Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I haven't seen very much conversation about the comparison between these two detectors now that the GPX 6000 is creeping into the SDC 2300's territory.  So far, the GPX gets both smaller and deeper gold.  Has anyone other observations?

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I sold my 2300 to help fund the 6000 purchase so my only observation was watching its new owner drive off with it 🙂 

seriously I think running the 2300 was  easier but the 6000 hits hard on any small metal target where as the 2300 would let you know its there...

strick 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Main issue for me was SDC poor ergonomics and hardwired coil. Even if they detected gold identically coil to coil, the GPX in the long run will benefit from a better coil selection, like that 17” mono. Still, for a person wanting a simple to operate, easy packing gold vacuum, the 2300 is a great little detector, and close to half the price of the 6000.

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree.  The cost is a big deal for many people.  Aside from cost, the physical characteristics are the main issue/point with the SDC.  It's compact and waterproof.  I've been curious if any long time users thought there were any remaining advantage of the SDC timings over the new GPX.  The SDC used to have a reputation for nicely handling hot rocks.  It seems pretty clear the GPX 6000 is more sensitive to small gold than the SDC. 

Does anyone with years of experience have an opinion on how these two compare with ironstones, soil mineralization, or salt signals?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Skookum said:

Does anyone with years of experience have an opinion on how these two compare with ironstones, soil mineralization, or salt signals?

The MPF timings for the SDC, in particular the receive processing, minimizes mineralized soil signals and can help greatly with hotrocks. The 6000 can be quite sensitive to hot rocks and the SDC has an edge IMO in extreme conditions. But overall the SDC is no match to the 6000. However, I still use it from time to time, especially when I go hiking. In highly mineralized soil with fast-timing shallow gold close over bedrock the SDC is hard to beat. It was designed for these conditions.

  • Like 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gold Catcher,

I agree. The only time I definitely chose the SDC is hiking down the steep slopes to the Yuba and American Rivers. The SDC fits nicely in my pack leaving both hands free. I hope to see you in November in Gold Basin.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the SDC will continue to be a great seller for a long time due to the facts already mentioned about it's compactness ease of use and ability to effectively handle mineralized ground...the main reason the guy that bought mine was because he could throw it into his back pack.  in 2014 I went on my last hunting trip...myself and two of my buddies back pack into a remote area in the Trinity Alps... it was a ritual we had been doing for close to 20 years...I threw the 2300 in my back pack and did not tell them I was loosing interest in deer hunting and would mainly be looking for gold...I wish I had a picture of them when we were un packing at our base camp when they watched my take the 2300 out of the pack. 

strick 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/4/2021 at 9:23 PM, Gold Catcher said:

The MPF timings for the SDC, in particular the receive processing, minimizes mineralized soil signals and can help greatly with hotrocks. The 6000 can be quite sensitive to hot rocks and the SDC has an edge IMO in extreme conditions.

I couldn't agree more.... this week a friend was visiting and we did extensive testing with a 5000 (various NF coils in size from the 8"x6" Sadie, up to the 25" DD), 2300, 6000 (11"/17" mono and included DD), 7000 (NF Z Search and OEM including the GPZ19) including in an area on my property that is littered in hot rocks. 2 years ago my friend using his SDC pulled 7 nice nuggets off the spot that this time using my 6000 he was not able to walk more than 5' without sounding on another hot rock, regardless of setting (N/D) or switching to the DD coil. The 6k was unusable, the 2300 dead quiet. If I had to sell one, it would be the 6k, for this reason, the utilitarian advantages of the SDC, waterproof for sniping, and the fact I have a 45,5, and 7 to cover the top range of the scale. The 6k is "not" an SDC killer in my opinion, the SDC is an incredible little machine FOR IT'S PURPOSE(S).

Jen

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would have to agree with what has already been said regarding the hot rocks....the SDC handles them better. The 6 gets the tiny nugs much deeper than the SDC though and, I would guess, the bigger ones deeper as well, though, I haven't got it over any sizeable nugs yet. I totally agree with Steve on ergonomics and coil selection...the 6 all the way! I did pull a small flat nug from a patch that had been totally flogged by the SDC with the 6 that was standing vertical in a crack and the 6 just sang out over this nug. It was the only signal left on this small patch. I'm guessing that it was missed by the SDC and every other machine because it was so thin and vertical. 

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/9/2021 at 9:25 AM, Jennifer said:

I couldn't agree more.... this week a friend was visiting and we did extensive testing with a 5000 (various NF coils in size from the 8"x6" Sadie, up to the 25" DD), 2300, 6000 (11"/17" mono and included DD), 7000 (NF Z Search and OEM including the GPZ19) including in an area on my property that is littered in hot rocks. 2 years ago my friend using his SDC pulled 7 nice nuggets off the spot that this time using my 6000 he was not able to walk more than 5' without sounding on another hot rock, regardless of setting (N/D) or switching to the DD coil. The 6k was unusable, the 2300 dead quiet. If I had to sell one, it would be the 6k, for this reason, the utilitarian advantages of the SDC, waterproof for sniping, and the fact I have a 45,5, and 7 to cover the top range of the scale. The 6k is "not" an SDC killer in my opinion, the SDC is an incredible little machine FOR IT'S PURPOSE(S).

Jen

Spot on Jen. This is the Achilles Heel of the GPZ 7000 and GPX 6000. Both detectors bang hard on certain hot rocks, generally the same hot rocks, that prior Minelab models can either reduce, or eliminate entirely. Usually in my case they are rare enough that digging them is more annoyance than problem, but if you get into locations where you hit them every few swings or more, they can pretty much shut a person down. That's why to this day I still advocate the GPX 5000 as the machine for all locations and situations over these two newer models, as it is in my opinion the most versatile Minelab PI made still. The SDC 2300 is also great, but more limited in coil selection and settings, so I give the overall nod to the 5000. In any case, I wanted to highlight your comment, as the newer GPZ 7000 and GPX 6000 get a lot of positive commentary from lots of people, including me. But it's important to note that for some locations they can be a total fail. There still is no one perfect machine for all situations, and may never be.

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Similar Content

    • By Northeast
      Morning everyone, 
      Had a search of the forum and although there are a few mentions of the 14" DD in various thread content I couldn't find a specific thread for discussion around it. 
      Did a video a few days ago getting a few small pieces of gold and small rubbish at a location I've found lots of small gold in a small area.  
      I know that I like watching videos and many of us often encourage others to do a video of this or that.  I figure that rather than asking everyone else to do it I should probably do some of the hard yards myself!  This is certainly not an advertisement of a Youtube channel and I have no illusions that my production quality or information provided is any better than fairly average  🤣
      Something for you Northern Hemisphere folk to watch during the cold months.  
      Happy for anyone to add to the discussion, link a video, show some DD finds or provide some tips on the thread.   
      The thing I found interesting about this was that the target shown at 3.55 mins was quite bright in Normal ground mode.  It ended up being no target at all and just a small pocket of really wet clay.  The fact that it brightened up with the DD surprises me.  The fact that it then brightened up quite a bit more in Normal maybe should have alerted me to the fact that it was ground noise and not a genuine target as the difference in signal on small pieces of gold swapping between Difficult and Normal has been quite small.
      Cheers, N.E.  
       
    • By Rob Allison
      Hello All,
          The new Minelab 17" Elliptical Searchcoils for the Minelab GPX 6000 have been flying off the shelves, definitely high demand.   Due to the high demand, I haven't had much time to use one, everyone ends of taking mine ... LOL
      I haven't seen much larger gold being found at depth yet, but I'm sure it is.  Curious how people and past customers are doing with this new 17" Searchcoil beyond covering more ground quicker?  
      We still have a few left in stock from the last large shipment and more on the way if anyone is still searching for a new "Christmas present.!"  Hahaha 
      Would love to see some pictures or at least hear about any success with the new searchcoil.  
      Wishing you all much success on the goldfield.
      17" Searchcoil available here - https://www.robsdetectors.com/minelab-gpx-6000-17-searchcoil/
      Rob
    • By Aureous
      Seeing how this topic has numerous mentions across the internet, what are the range of faults exhibited? My nearest dealer is over an hour from me so I don't want to travel back and forth after picking mine up if I get a faulty one. So I know what to look for after collection and field test. 
    • By oldcoinhunter
      My first 6000 was faulty out of the box which they replaced with a new one. I've had the new one for 21 days and probably used it 8 days before it went bad.  When i was boxing it up to ship back i heard something rattling inside of it, not good. In researching i found that they've known them to have major issues since March or April, yet they have refused to address the issue with a production stop or at least look at the different production runs and recall those units. I think when it's all said and done there will be a substantial number of them that are faulty worldwide. As it stands now, Detector Center states that there is a" temporary" 10- 14 day time frame for repairing them. My bet is that it's not going to be temporary. If this failure rate continues there may be grounds for a worldwide class action lawsuit, who knows. Oh, and i owned a business for 40 years. Not a very smart way to run a business. JMO.
    • By Smithsgold
      Nugget Hunting a Hydraulic Pit 
      Me and Gary  @Two Toes  head deep into the Sierra's in search of those elusive Gold Nuggets the Old timers missed.
      Yes I include Gary in with the Old Timers as he has Detected this spot before. Nugget Hunting in a Hydraulic pit isn't the easiest thing to do but it's one of the funnest and most rewarding ways of finding Gold.
      On this adventure we take three different Metal Detectors The Minelab SDC 2300, White's TDI, and a White's Gold Master V-Sat this allows us to use both Pulse Induction and VLF technologies in our search for Gold and Treasures.
      Watch as we pull those Gold Nuggets the old timers missed over a hundred years ago out of the ground !!!!!
      Gary finds a old Lead soldered painted Can with Gold inside what did the Old timers us it for ? I find Six musket balls encased in rotting wood how long have those been there ?
      Plus Many many old square Nails !!!!!
      Thanks for watching I hope you enjoyed the adventure we sure had fun finding all the cool stuff and wondering what and how they used it.
      SG 046
       
       
    • By Dutchman4
      I am in the market for a used SDC 2300 and wanted to know if there have been any software/firmware or hardware updates since the first introduction in 2014?
      Are there any pros/cons of buying an older machine lets say 5 years old vs a 1 year old machine?
      Are the supplied oem headphones satisfactory or is it better to invest in better headphones?
      Is the Lithium Battery upgrade a good investment and does it come with a charger?
      Thanks in advance
×
×
  • Create New...