Jump to content

Knowing When To Move On

Recommended Posts

As I stating in Gerry's Topic "Does Size and or Success Matter?" I have a follow up question for folks. Again there is no right or wrong answer, more just an open discussion on what you do.

When do you consider a patch played out? Do you keep expanding the area even though you've been skunked several times? If so how far do you keep going? How often do you go back to "played out" patches in hopes for finding the ones left behind? Will you scrape a whole are searching for deeper bits? I could keep going on with more questions but I think you are getting my point. When do YOU finally say "I'm done here". 

I am slightly expecting different answers between those who are hobbyist and those who do this for a living. I would expect those who do this for a living to move on once it does not make financial sense to stay there, but it also might not be as much fun to pick up your scraps when there could be more virgin patches near by. I think this is an interesting topic to discuss and I am curious to see what the more experienced members here have to say!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's a very good question and I look forward to seeing the feedback you get. On my last trip Einstein's definition of insanity ( "doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results") kept going through my mind.

But to answer your question, personally I'd say move on after a) about 3 attempts with no success at all or b) when you've run out of different things to do on the same patch. I attach my score sheet so far and this is for bone dry, very rocky, low mineralization ground with thin soil all done with a GB2. I have an ATX but it mostly stays in the truck. Also I don't do this for a living; it has to be the world's worst business model!

As you can see the law of diminishing returns generally applies in both size and number of nuggets. In my case keeping a patch alive has been mostly due to moving rocks, switching from a 10" to 6" coil and sheer bloody mindedness. But that only delays the inevitable. There are exceptions. I'd kinda given too much credit to the "old timers", stayed out of worked dry washes and so I didn't find patch 6 until my third attempt. It took me six attempts to find the Patch 2 channel extension (eat your heart out Einstein)!. But, 3 dry runs or when plumb out of ideas seems sane.


  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

48 minutes ago, Jonathan Porter said:

as such none of my areas are truly played out.

Aye, I suspect that is true of all our backyards, I just shake my head in resignation/disbelief each time another close in patch is found, when to move on??????😉 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

    Just to state up front, this may belong in a different category!  I'm not a nugget or dink hunter, due mostly to my location in Florida!

   That being said, I like the questions asked for two reasons!

   **Firstly, I find all you nugget hunters experiences interesting, and feel like I learn alot from you all!

   **And secondly; and more applicable to me, and others here, I think there are some parallels in the questions asked, with other types of detecting!

   Are any places where people have congregated ever played out? Like gold; do coins, jewelry, artifacts, etc... every really run out in an area, or are they just waiting to be exposed by various events, or more sophisticated equipment and/or techniques?

    Being that many of you may also hunt other items in the same areas, I just thought some of the answers here may serve us all in that respect!!👍👍


  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 When the season is over.

2 When the wife says not there again.

3 When I have to go over the same ground twice.

4 When I get sick of the area.

5 When I think I'm being followed. 

6 When I feel like looking for a new virgin. 😀

7 Forget all above, ...... When I upgrade my Detector and I have to justify it's purchase. 

  • Like 4
  • Haha 4
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

When is it time to move on?

The right question should be Have I really covered every inch of this place to justify moving on.

The reason I say that is when I was detecting an old church for the 4th time, I realized that there was just one place that I had not covered. When I did detect there the tones just rang out. That was where the out house and fire pit was located and it had a lot of trash still there. I had found dimes and trimes when I checked those places and then it hit me, check everything and every inch more than once.

Gold fields are the same and have to be the hardest areas to detect for sure, but move some rock a little dirt, and listen for the tones. They will still produce gold but maybe not as much as you would like.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not a gold hunter here, but I would think that if you have a lot of free time, then hunting old patches is not a bad thing. It can also be therapeutic to visit places of fond memories. But if you are limited on time, then hunting new patches seems a better bet, even though you may strike out a lot. But hunting new ground also has a sense of adventure and can recharge you so detecting doesn't get stale after a while. I hunt my same areas a lot because they can renew themselves, where gold hunting can produce again generally only if you physically remove layers of dirt (discounting new technology). So to stay or move would be a choice that involves how you think and feel internally and not so much if the area is still producing gold. The is no logical reason to keep reworking the same patch just to get scraps, yet a lot of people still do that. So maybe it's more of a philosophical question than a logical one. I say this because I will be detecting the same beach I always do next time out 😆

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Similar Content

    • By Dutchman4
      After a 6 year break I decided to start metal detecting for nuggets again.
      Background:   I used to live in Temecula, CA and used to go to the Dale Mining District as well as the El Paso mountains.  Back then, I started by taking a metal detecting prospecting field trip taught by Michael Greyshock.  I used a Gold Bug Pro with the DP coil at that time and it was pretty tough with the iron stone in the Dale Mining District.  I later purchased a Garret ATX but only used it a few times and sold it for a variety of reasons.  It had great electronics but in a terrible package.  Also the falsing when bumping against anything would drive me nuts.  Anyway after 4 years of prospecting I got tired of digging trash and spending lonely nights in the dessert, so I gave it up.
      I retired last year when I turned 60 and my wife and I moved from Scal to Mesquite, NV.  I recently purchased a SDC 2300 and thought I would give it a try again.  I still have the Gold Bug Pro with all 3 coils also.  Gold Basin is about a 3 hour drive and I plan to go there tuesday and return on thursday.  I use "Backcountry Navigator" on my tablet for maps and gps navigation.  I looked up the currently active claims on "thediggings.com" website and see they are pretty much clustered in the middle of the basin area.  It would be handy to have a gpx or kmz overlay map file of the active claims that I could load on my tablet but I don't know if something like that exists.  I prefer to detect on BLM land instead of claims and I don't mind getting remote and hiking.  This will be my first trip to GB and any pointers or advice would be appreciated.  I drive a brown 2010 Toyota Tundra double cab 4x4 long bed, with a color matched camper shell and NV plates,  in case any of you are in GB on the same days and would like to say Hi.
      Regards,  Ceril      
    • By Dutchman4
      I searched the forums and was not able to find an answer to this question:
      So when I find a used Minelab SDC 2300 how do I go about verifying that it is authentic when I go to inspect it with the seller?
      I looked on the minelab website and it appears there are several methods that dont require you to take it to a dealer but it is not clear to me how it is done.
      Is there a hologram viewer supplied with a new unit and then you enter the sn# plus the hidden code into minelab online verification app?
    • By mcjtom
      I’m not sure where to post it: would anybody know a good documentary on metal detecting/treasure hunting (technology, applications, history) of interest to upper high school students?
    • By trunkmonkey
      Is the Green Aftermarket Coil Tab Protector used "to replace" the teardrop washers?  
      In other words, if the coil of my machine is equipped with the "Green Aftermarket Coil Tab Protector," then there is No Need To Be Concerned About the fact that the teardrop washers can not be used in the set up; is that correct?
      Is the following a true statement:
      "The teardrop washers and the fact that they do not fit in place any where in conjunction with an installed "Green Aftermarket Coil Tab Protector" is of no consequence." 
      I sure hope so because I can see absolutely no possible way that the teardrop washers can be used in conjunction with the 
      "Green Aftermarket Coil Tab Protector"
      Best Regards,
      Steve E. Bryant 
    • By Alex.mexico
      I recently was looking at a new place when I was hiking and found some interesting samples. I bought a cheap digital microscope to get a closer look and think I found something good but want some opinions before I get them assayed. Anyone want to help?

    • By mcjtom
      I'm a total newbie.  I bought an inexpensive detector called Quick Shooter MD3030.  It came from China to Thailand and it also doubles as 'Mental Detector' judging from the picture below. 
      I think I understand more or less by now what it does - there is a sensitivity and selectivity (including notching out in 6 phase shift ranges) target identification value display plus 3 tones audio for different ID ranges.  It operates on single frequency of some 6 kHz and seems to have round coils.
      There is also 'depth indicator' on the display, which I imagine would be the return signal/target strength (or the inverse of it)?  I'm not sure if I understand how VLF detectors know the depth of the target.
      Would anybody be vaguely or intimately familiar with this detector and are there is any technical info or reviews, beyond what I know that I can consult to learn more about it?  I don't even know who the manufacturer is...
      A related question: since this detector doesn't have a background threshold control, would decreasing sensitivity play a similar function?
      I know that this particular model may not be up to the Board Members' standards but please help the newbie.
      Many thanks!
  • Create New...