Jump to content
hayesman76

Metal Detecting With A Knee Replacement?

Recommended Posts

No, not talking about carrying around the patella of Jeff Williams’s buddy Slim while prospecting with a metal detector but, instead, the possibility of metal detecting after having had knee replacement surgery.

Probably due in part to excessive jogging and running before, during and after military service, I’m now the owner of a very arthritic knee and considering getting a knee replacement. Almost all such replacements use some type of metal as main components.

Just wondering if anyone reading this metal detects despite having a knee replacement. Does/would a metallic knee replacement make metal detecting impossible because the materials used in the replacement would constantly be giving false readings?

I checked for previous threads on this topic and, to my surprise, didn’t find anything, which is why I’m bringing the subject up now.

Since a lot of baby boomers, who probably comprise a large percentage of detectorists, may have/will eventually have knee problems I look forward to any insights they or anyone else can share!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm pretty much in the same boat and have held off for a couple of reasons. First off knee replacement is an iffy proposition they can be heaven sent or hell bent or anywhere in between. My brother (younger) had both knees replaced (bad knees run in the family) and has had great success, a friend has had one replaced (about 6 months ago) and has had nothing highly painful difficulty with it. He's an older person, 78 I think, has gone to therapy regularly as directed by his Dr and done everything else he was told to do and yet he moves around like he's 178. I probably should have had the replacements done years ago but I just can't get myself to do it because of possibly not being able to prospect and not being able to walk well afterword. Still on the fence.

Mike

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hear you. One of my cousins had a knee replacement and he says it’s one of the best things he’s done. He does go to the gym and does the recommended physical therapy. OTOH, a former colleague who had a knee replacement after retiring wasn’t so lucky and has had major problems with his — probably because (as I’ve been told) he didn’t do the required post-operation exercises/physical therapy.

I’ve seen mention of a plastic-based knee replacement and, assuming it contains no metals whatsoever (doubtful) it’d be a Godsend for metal detectorists with knee problems. I’ll see if I can find any more info about that variety of replacement.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know of a very successful prospector in OZ here that had such a knee replacement, once on the mend he had no choice but give up his GPZ 7000 and return to using a PI with a smaller coil, only one thing will stop him prospecting I suspect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My same conscerns applied to my choice to operate.  I had a partial knee replacement several years ago, and no sensitivity issues discovered with my ZED.  After being warned about metal eyelets on my shoes affecting the then new GPZ 7000 on sweeps, I was similarly concerned about my knee doing such.  

I can only say that I can’t find any difference, EXCEPT having to kneel down while digging those tunnels to China on deep targets.  I’d waited too long, IMHO, to have the knee operated on, and believe the lower leg muscles attrified a bit by my ‘favoring’ them.  It’s getting better, but still not a fan of the deep targets - EXCEPT, they usually produce AU.

That said, traveling through TSA security check points at airports, usually means hand-wanding and a ‘feel-up’ job to clear security. :blink:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OK, going off at a tangent, about 6 months ago I was put onto this stuff.  I`ve had bad knees, elbows and wrists for years and for me this stuff is a miracle cure.  I don`t think it`s a placebo thing because the first time I applied it I really didn`t think it would work.  You may notice it says not for human use but for horses and dogs only, and I don`t care. For the first time in 25 years I am pain free in my wrists. I put a mate onto it a month ago and he now uses it daily for his knees. The guy that put me onto it has been using it for 20 years for arthritic hands. One of our chemist chains over here even sells the stuff.  The funny thing is, they don`t sell anything else for horses or dogs. 
Try it or don`t try it. Completely up to you.  Dave
Sorry Steve if this is too off topic.
https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=m570.l1313&_nkw=rapigel&_sacat=0

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have just had a full knee replacement and very concerned about the effect using my Z. I'm still on the recovery road only a month since surgery. I'm heading out in about 2weeks, fingers crossed. I will inform you how things go. There might be a cheap Z up for sale :sad:

 

Edited by Outback54
Wrong name
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a friend who does it just can't kneel down close to the coil when digging targets

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 hours ago, Outback54 said:

I have just had a full knee replacement and very concerned about the effect using my Z. I'm still on the recovery road only a month since surgery. I'm heading out in about 2weeks, fingers crossed. I will inform you how things go. There might be a cheap Z up for sale :sad:

 

Hopefully not. Heal up well and fast!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm just 8 months into complete knee replacement, did some detecting with G.B.2 and pin pointer Garrett Pro-Pointer AT and had no problems, I do recommend a very good pair of knee pads and frozen gel packs for when you get finished for the day !!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Noah (FL)
      EDITED.........For a first timer just doing some experimental nugget hunting would it be worth a GPAA membership for access to the claims or just doing some research and hunting BLM land?  Will be in Phoenix visiting a friend after a work trip that ends in Vegas. I am entertaining renting a car instead of flying and trying my luck for nuggets along the way!  
      Thanks...Noah
       
       
      What group/club is best for AZ or NV gold detecting claims???   First time detector prospector looking for a nugget!!!
      Relic/coin hunter from Florida planning a vacation.    Thanks
    • By nugget hunter
      has any one air test the scuba tector on large objects ????? i like to know it max range ......i seen its worthless on very small targets ....whats it range on a helmet , rifle ,  truck size object ....the targets i look for  are 12 to 24 inches deep could the scuba tector in wet sand go this deep ???  or does it max out at 12" am guessing 2.5x the coil size like other pi detectors do ....
    • By nugget hunter
      any info or ideas  on what would find more nuggets ?????
    • By Swifty
      Seeing that most of the regular posters are experienced detector users, I'm a little curious what type of threshold  you prefer.
      I've noticed there seems to be 3 main choices for threshold.
      1. Running hot, detector sounds a little unstable but still a target stands out from the rest of the sounds.
      2. Running smooth and steady listening for any change in sound at all.
      3. Running close to, or actually silent with a target the only sound made excepting an occasional EMI burst.
      And second are you using headphones?
      I run my 7000 close to silent, and my discrimination detectors with a smooth threshold.
      I use headphones on everything.
    • By Gerry in Idaho
      On my FB a few weeks ago I posted a photo of a thin metal tin rectangular in shape that had Chinese writing on it. Yes I know it is an opium tin, but what does the symbols say? Found these 3 at an old mining site with Equinox. Thanks for your help.



    • By Bhogg
      Hi Everyone just wondering about Gold Nugget Settings?.
      I haven’t seen or heard  much about Settings for hunting small nuggets and also hunting them in highly mineralised soils?.
      Very interested to see how it’s going to compare against the Gold Monster, as it’s very sensitive on very Tiny bits.
      So if anyone’s been having some great success with it I’d love it if you could please share some settings and tips.
      Thanks Everyone for your time and help it’s greatly appreciated!!.
       Cheers All
×