Jump to content

Recommended Posts

This seems mighty weird, a guy on our local auction site is selling hundreds of roman coins from between 100 and 400 AD for $1 each, about 70 US cents I guess.

Claims they were found with metal detectors.

https://www.trademe.co.nz/antiques-collectables/coins/ancient/listing-1853382900.htm?rsqid=9420490cdc564a5cb2786431be84466f

 

888155205.jpg

Are these things likely to be fakes or are low grade roman coins really worth that little?

 

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Simon… I’m not qualified to state any opinion on Roman coins, because they don’t interest me at all. Viewing those coins in your photo, they don’t look very appealing. But then, how do we assign a value to historical interest? For example, I have a good collection of modern dug silver coins that are worn and not likely worth more than their silver bullion value. But I wouldn’t part with those coins, and certainly not for the sake of a dollar or two.

I suppose that it also partly depends on one’s character. I place a high value on the finds that I made as a result of my resourcefulness, hard work, and personal expense. Coins and jewelry aside, it’s inconceivable to me to even consider parting with any of my prospecting recoveries. I want to see those rocks tastefully displayed in my den, and nothing else will do.

Mind you, that’s not to pass judgement on those who do sell their finds, it’s strictly an individual decision. I’m afraid that this is not a terribly coherent reply Simon, but I do think that you will understand my point of view…………………Jim. 

1962017174_1.9LBDENDRITICAGCALCITESF17YGBLACK.JPG.fc7104b91244eef2499e9e7c2cae5b48.JPG

2061789202_PROSPECTINGAGCOINSSFYG16.JPG.da77fccc75bdb813b7f3b147da7a69b1.JPG

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I understand completely Jim, I wouldn't part with any of my finds either! Selling isn't an option, I'd be more likely to give as a gift to someone who really loved one of my finds than sell one if I knew they wanted it for the right reasons.  My finds certainly mean more to me than their monetary value which is pretty low in the scheme of things.  Most of my nuggets would be lucky to be worth the money I spent on a drink they day I found them 🙂

I was just surprised to see someone in NZ had hundreds of Roman coins found with a metal detector they were willing to sell for 1 NZD each.  If they were my finds I'd have a lot of trouble parting with them, especially for $1 each! I wouldn't see that as worthwhile that's for sure.

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like a coin dealer based on the many other coins that are for sale by the same person. These coins look to be too much work to clean vs the money that would be generated by them if cleaned.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi,

Maybe the Romans went to NZ as well and, up to now, nobody knew about it.....? 😉

 

But seriously...in Europe there are a lot of roman coins found (on some French fora I even saw them called  "Roros" sometimes (- as in "today I found this ["interesting object"] and some roros"). A lot are "far gone" and/or not (very) rare and therefore have no great monetary value.  I'm still looking to find the first one myself though, here in Belgium. 😊

Greetings,

Bob'ke

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My only Roman coin find was later ID’d by a museum as 2nd century AD from Mesopotamia.  Head of a man on one side, head of a woman on the other.  Silver, but essentially worthless.

The only interesting thing about it was that I found it on the edge of a scrapyard outside Riyadh Saudi Arabia - on the surface.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Simon, those coins are called "grots" (Grotty) and the price being asked is correct for coins devoid of numismatic value. More desirable specimens are likely to cost $5.00 and up. HH Jim

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a Roman coin the is very badly worn...I bought it to have something that I will never find for myself- about 5 bucks...

fred

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From the looks of these "toasted" coins and the given date range of 100 - 400 AD they are probably from Britain. This is the date range from Claudius' major invasion in 43 AD to the Romans leaving around 383 AD. Fields with heavy fertilizer tended to turn the coins green and impart significant damage. The darker and black coins tend to be in better condition. The "grotty greenies" with no detail are virtually worthless  while some of the darker coins with detail are worthy of a little investigation. The dark coin in the front right center shows two soldiers holding an military standard. This is a classic reverse of many Roman coins especially around 330-348 AD. 

There is not much of a thrill in buying a "grotty greenie" but there is an emotional rush in finding one and knowing you are the first person in almost 2,000 years to be holding it.

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 11/29/2018 at 1:32 AM, Jimmy M said:

Simon, those coins are called "grots" (Grotty) and the price being asked is correct for coins devoid of numismatic value. More desirable specimens are likely to cost $5.00 and up. HH Jim

That about sums up what those coins are and what they are worth,i have bags of them that i have found over the years and i mean bag loads,they are worth almost zero money wise,chemicals that man has put on the ground over the decades has also not helped the condition,but they have basically just been attacked by various acids etc in the ground,animal urine and many other things just kill them and as been mentioned thy are just 'grotty' coins and usually end up in the junk area of your finds bag,folks still cannot grasp that something that is nearly 2000 years old is worth basically peanuts and the reason why is they are very common and the condition is abysmal and hence the cheap price.

Silver roman dinari and the most desirable and scarcest of all roman coins are roman gold solidus,the solidus is the holy grail in my mind of our finds.,as of course no banks or other forms of security institutions had been around at that time and when the romans withdrew  around 400AD they basically just left and of course many many hoards and also many other smaller single soldier wage finds are also found and almost all found with metal detectors.

So they do look authentic but nothing mind blowing value wise,unless its a mint condition and very scares silver or the holy grail again gold solidus,i have been detecting with a club on a roman trading villa site for 10+ years and the finds still keep coming in vast amounts,almost all are 'grotty' finds as well,but of course over the years some desirable gold ones have also been found on this site.

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By kac
      Sometimes I do a quick search on old coins I find on ebay for quickie reference on what people are selling them for and think I found a counterfeit ring going on. See back of this quarter for example:
      You will notice where there is detail it is raised more which leads me to believe that it was created from a 3d scan. I say that because typically 3d scanner will not have enough resolution no matter how good and will average the heights when details are too close and small causing a puffiness in that area. A coin back then was done from a large master and milled on a pantograph milling machine. 
      Now coins dies are made from edm (electrical discharge machining) where a graphite master is burned into the die then it's polished.
      Anyways the prices on them are ridiculously low and there seems to be a lot of subtle oddities that make me suspicious. The example I showed a real 1943 silver in half descent condition would be around $20-$30 and not $0.99.
      Who do I contact on that? Does ebay care?
      Anyways buyer beware on that.
    • By normmcq
      Knowing that my coin would never be graded as a very expensive coin although very desirable, I decided to make it look better for my personal viewing. I looked at a lot of U tube videos and read several things about cleaning silver without damaging the object. Just wanting to know the outcome before trying the method on my coin,. I tried it on other objects. I settled on using cotton balls, Q tips and non abrasive Carnuba oil auto polish. This didn't seem to leave any scratches, only cleaned and polished it. As you can see, all of the scratches and marks from being in the ground for about 140 plus years are still there.




    • By calabash digger
      This how I clean my iron relics using electrolysis..
       
    • By Lobo Lover
      Hello to All Members,
                                            We have been finding many pre-decimal New Zealand Coins. After washing off the dirt they are covered in a layer of patina, that dull brown stuff which we have been reading should not be removed for poor technique will devalue the coins worth. Toothbrushes, bristle brushes, chemical compounds and polishing cloths are a No-No, but they look so nice and shiny to a novice like me.  Also just to let you guys know that electrolysis is not the way to go that ate a few of my good coins.
            We have been reading  that valuable coins are "Best left to a Professional", so it can be done the proper way!  What do they use? How do they do it without depreciating the value of the coin? Is there a knowledgeable Coin Expert who is willing to divulge their secrets, not for me but for the sake of the coin? 
            Failing that, how should the coin be presented to a potential buyer or collector with this patina on it? Because it doesn't look very nice like this, underneath is a beautiful coin and I would like to get fair trade value for them. Will they appreciate our respect for the coin in this condition by leaving it this way?
            Some are very nice and valuable judging from coin evaluation sites and others not so much. How can I decide which coins to show? Even some pennies are very sought after and small silver ones which are a rarity. What do I do, What do I do? Hum.
    • By Chris Ben
      Hi all. I made it out Sunday for a nice hunt. Great weather temp wise, maybe a little windy. I want back to the wash I found the nuggets in a couple of weeks back, and was able to squeak out 1 more. I tried to expand the area but not luck. I picked up and headed to an area that has been mined a lot, full of trash, but I figure must be full of gold. Wow I really am amazed what the GPZ is capable of.  2 of the nuggets I found really amazed me, size and depth. 1 of those I was detecting a drywash header pile and got a small repeatable signal. I kept raking back the rocks, still getting the signal till I got to virgin ground under the pile, 6 more inches down I pulled out a sub gram nugget. Amazing. 
      All 4 for the day added up to 3.8 grams.
      Now to the question,  I've been soaking that big quartz specimen I found in Wink for about a month now, it is exposing more gold, very slowly. How long do I soak? Do I need to refresh the wink? The longer I soak it the more quartz will dissolve? 
      Thanks Chris 
    • By Andy2640
      Hi Ya'll
      Well im now building up a huge collection of various finds.   Ive got so many British 1800 and 1900 pennies, half pennies and farthings that i dont know what to do with them all.  But also some really nice silver sixpences, half crowns, florins and other nice silver coins.  Other items are rings x2, musket balls, badges and roman/medievil weights.
      Question is, how do you lovely buggers store your finds?  Be it coin cabinets, display cases or just sprawled over your desk.  Do you lot keep only the best coins for display, or show everything you find?  See im not sure whether to display only the cream of the crop, or enjoy everything, both the good, the bad and the down right ugly.
      Would love to see your collection displays, coin trays, etc and your thoughts on finds which meet either the ... "keep/throw/stash or display criteria".  Hopefully you'll give me and others some ideas ...and of course inspiration 😉
       
      Cheers peeps.
       
      Andy.
       
×
×
  • Create New...