Jump to content
bamajoe

Can A GPX Or Sd 2300 Discriminate Iron?

Recommended Posts

I doubt that we have much gold here in Alabama, we're too far from the beach, and not much civil war fought here, so, that leaves coin shooting . However, we do have lots of iron in the ground (bad soil) and rusty nails. Will the GPX's, SD2200's or 2300's actually discriminate  iron good enough to be able to go a little deeper than my CTX3030? My CTX is good for about 4" in worst soil and 7" at best. I need something to get a little deeper. The only PI's that I've owned is the original TDI several years back and presently have a TDI SL. The original TDI was deeper than the SL and I was thinking that I could tell small iron nails while adjusting GB would lose nails at "5" on GB then continuing to hear hi conductors on down to "3" on GB. I can in no way tell a rusty nail from a high conductor with the TDL SL. Will any PI discriminate good enough to detect only high conductors? IF no, then I'm waiting on the Fisher Manta. Thanks, Joe

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Manta will be in the same boat.  Loosing the high conductive nails will loose high conductive silver. The tester that posts as LeJag on Dankowskis forum has discussed it a few times. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Basically, no. The GPX is about as good as it gets with both tones and a shallow iron disc function, but it is far from perfect. Garrett ATX the same but not as powerful.

Minelab GPX Discrimination

GPX Iron Reject

The Manta no matter what they say will have ferrous limitations. Nature of the beast.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Running a GP series or GPX4000 or 4500 in the Salt timing will as part of the timing lose some very small low conductors. 

Also a big DD will achieve the same. But the actual Iron Reject circuit will only reject iron target that it is sure is iron, i.e. small and deep iron will still signal as normal. 

Thanks for linking my article Steve. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the help.. Steve, I read all the 2015 treads from Paul from California...I think that is "OLD California" on some other sites. Started to message Paul but he hasn't posted in several months...just hope his health is okay....Yeah, I'm beginning to realize the PI iron limitations that you are referring to. Have only used a TDI PI machine that apparently more limited as compared to ATX, SDC, or GPX...I was just hoping that the GPX would be so deep that maybe it could discriminate iron to at least 7" in my bad soil....If it could then it would help me get beyond my VLF limit. I want to try a GPX or the newly released Fisher I Pulse AQ....Not sure when the AQ will be available for purchase and not sure if much advantage over the GPX...however, the price said to be between $2100 and $2500 is about the same as a new GPX4500....about $1000 less than a new GPX5000....if I had your money then it would be such a proble..I'd just get both. Thanks, Joe 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The TDI rejects ferrous as well as any of them if not better due to the manual GB control. I wrote the original article about it. I can use a TDI and dig minimal ferrous, but then it gets no more or less depth than a good VLF.

Paul has left all the forums. The last place I saw him post was Findmall. He might still be on Geotech.

It would be nice to be free of monetary concerns. You own more PI detectors than I do right now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By Tnsharpshooter
      This will be where I will post information.  I will try and answer any questions I can about detector.  Other folks who have experience with detector and wish to join in, by all means do so.
      Should have detector today sometime.  Thought I would get this thread started to save time later.  I will only be using Tarsacci on turf, not salt water/sand application.
      I may do some testing on freshwater beach due to lower minerals present.
      For refererence  - Quick start guide
       https://drive.google.com/file/d/12ecPA1jFF7JOGZLYYywMxZeeyW5qqkMd/view
      User Manual
      https://drive.google.com/file/d/1jYhFnstUqLuo5eV28aEZsj9wfeY2TRt-/view
      Tarsacci MDT 8000 Data & Reviews
    • By kac
      I recently broke a vow and took my Tejon to the beach and surprisingly did pretty well. I came across this ring about 4-6" down in the damp sand.
      It has no makers mark or any marks, the diamonds look like cz's not real diamonds as they refract some color and huff test they do not fog. When I compared the vdi on it from my AT Pro it comes in as a solid 55. Stainless rings come in at 48, titanium around 50 and 14k come in at solid 52 on that machine. Jeffersons come in at 52. Usually in my past experience 55 is a square tab or junk. Anyone know what range white gold comes in on?
      Weight is .3 oz
       

    • By stolik333
      Hi all users DetectorProspector. I want to buy detector for relic ( roman silver/gold coins, celtic axes and middle ages relic) . Now I use Minelab Sovereign Elite, but in last 3- 4 month's not found nothing interesting (everywhere were before me) . And I think what need to buy detector PRO - level. But I'm confused. My choice fell to 3 devices:

      Minelab GPX 5000
      Whites TDI PRO/SL
      Nexus Standart MP

      or 50/50 choice

      Blistool v6
      Tarsacci mdt 8000
      Minelab ctx3030

      or Yours alternative's. 

      Please tell me, what metal detector is the deepest for relic hunting? And can good work to heavy soil? Thanks

      P.S. Sorry to my English
    • By stolik333
      Hi all users DetectorProspector.. I want to buy detector for thin gold jewelry : chain, earrings (underwater search) . Now I use Tesoro Compadre but not enough depth . And I think what need to buy detector PRO - level with high frequency. But I'm confused. My choice fell to 3 devices:

      GoldenMask One 24
      Deeptech Vista Gold / Gold Gain
      Whites TDI Beach Hunter

      or Yours alternative's. 

      Please tell me, what metal detector is the deepest for thin jewelry? And can good work to heavy soil? Thanks

      P.S. Sorry to my English
    • By Danny Atherton
      Hey guys, 
      My first time posting here, hopefully I'm not breaking any rules! 
      My mother recently took some of her old gold jewelry to be melted down into a bracelet. While she was there the jeweler pulled out one of her bracelets saying it was too valuable and shouldn't be melted down. So that's got me trying to find out more about it and what type of chain it is.
      So far no luck! I thought you guys might know something and have some suggestions whether she should sell it or not! 
      Cheers! 
      Danny. 
       



    • By leon
      Hi
      Neighbor lost a 3/4 carat diamond earing w/small white gold post.
      I tried my old Eagle ll sl  & Bounty hunter 101 but they don't seem to be sensitive enough.
      Any suggestions??
×
×
  • Create New...