Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Klunker, On the River, Prospecting thread, you alluded to the superiority of the steel pan. Some people booed your opinion. I've used a steel pan forever because it's substantial and I hate plastic; almost every piece of plastic gear falls apart relatively quickly. But I'd like to know your reasoning for its superiority over the plastic ones. Does it retain the gold better? And I think a few other guys were curious, too. Thanks, no rush, Joel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Klunker is getting prett.y old and forgetful, I think he likes it because it is easier to find with has detector

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
30 minutes ago, normmcq said:

 Klunker is getting prett.y old and forgetful, I think he likes it because it is easier to find with has detector

:laugh:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

normmcq, Love it, but it`d have to be a big pan, the lads a wee deaf I suspect.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The crows in my backyard have taken a fondness for one of my plastic gold pans.

image.jpeg

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Some of you poor souls probably lost appreciable amounts of gold from your plastic pans while waiting for my response to this thread. My heartfelt apologies but I was at the claim testing a new depth increaser accessory  for the GPZ 7000.

 Re; plastic vs. steel pans. Use your 6 natural senses.

1. I listen for a change of sound that tells my the courser material has worked it's way to the bottom.

2. The riffles and the inset bottom ring of a plastic pan may hid a tiny particle of gold when the knowledge of finding gold is much more important than the values in the pan.

3. When you get down to the final concentrates a very light delicate working of the pan is vital. Plastic pans just don't have the right balance and feel.

4. Plastic pans just don't smell good.

5. Pancakes cooked in a plastic pan taste funny.

6. The spirits tell me that just because it's new doesn't make it better.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I appreciate your points.... You just like steel pans!

I almost never use the riffles in a plastic pan and never bought any with an inset bottom.

But, I can hear the course material hit the bottom of a plastic pan.......

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"5. Pancakes cooked in a plastic pan taste funny."

Pancakes taste especially good with a dose of rust from steel pans....

what special device were you testing, Mr. Klunker?

fred

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It seems like the taste in gold pans is similar to liking a certain guitar to play. And Klunker & I just like the feel of steel, What do they use in the Gold Panning Championships? That contest is based on retention. I gotta blue mine up for a coming trip to the old N Yuba to pan the fines from Vak-Pak-ing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Jim in Idaho
      I've been trying to come up with a unit to recover gems dry, but finally realized that the "granular convection" problem can't be defeated. In the process of building and trying various ideas, I came up with this unit. While the dry recovery of gems requires some very tight classifying, and thus isn't practical, I tried it for gold, and was simply amazed at its abilities for heavy metals. I have tried it on all sorts of raw materials, running bank feed at roughly 2" minus, and have yet to find a material it doesn't work on to one extent or another.
       I ran it dry...no water, on damp material at the LDMA Blue Bucket outing near Baker, Oregon a few weeks ago, and recovered flour and black sand from old tailings from previous outings. Running wet, the day before, on new material I recovered very near 100% on black sand and gold in front of several witnesses. They suggested re-running the tails, and zero black sand, or gold was found. Last weekend I attended a local club outing at Salmon, Idaho. The material was a heavy clay with lots of rocks....not a fun material, at all. At the common dig, one of the guys next to me, running a highbanker, mentioned that my little unit was handling the clay really well. I was the only person running 2" minus directly into the machine, and the rocks were agitating the material so the clay broke down, and the rocks were mostly clean before they went out to tails. The day prior to the common dig I went down to the locale the common material had been hauled from, and ran the material dry. This was  a nasty, damp material. I expected nothing and was surprised to see both black sand and gold when I did the cleanup. Certainly I lost quite a bit, but any recovery working dry from damp material is an accomplishment. This unit works wet or dry. Very little dust running dry. Very low water requirement when running wet...roughly 50 gallons/hour.
       The full utility US Patent has been applied for.
       You can see the prototype running at Bonanza Bar on the Snake, along with pics of the recovery here:  
       
      Jim
    • By kiwijw
      Hi there RR, All this gadget is doing is mechanically classifying material into a gold pan. Nothing you couldn't do with a manual classifier over your gold pan which you could possibly get away with. I know with my sluice boxing I made & use a bucket classifier than can process a lot of material pretty quickly to feed down the box. 
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
      Clean up time
       

      Good luck out there
      JW 
    • By idahogold
      Super Cool! If it can handle the punishment of Hardcore Diggers? Enjoy! Cheers, Ig
       
    • By Steve Herschbach
      I tripped over this extensive article, available as a free download. Here is the abstract:
      The article sets out to clarify the special character of the North American gold pan and why it remains so popular – in spite of widespread dissatisfaction and many modifications and innovations. The North American pan is distinctive in being circular with a flattish floor ringed by an outwardly sloping wall. Its identity is confused by over-use of the terms 'pan' and 'panning'. The North American pan gyrates in a distinctive orbital motion driven by both hands of the panner. Although many other motions are resorted to (tapping, to-and-fro, tilting, and tick-tock), it is the orbital motion and flattish floor that together distinguish the pan from most other hand-held gravitational devices. In spite of its enduring popularity, no scientific tests have been published on the North American gold pan or for any of the innovations covered by 30 US patents awarded since 1861. It remains unclear if the North American gold pan is more efficient at recovering fine gold and flat gold than is a lotok, batea, dulang, ninja bowl, grizzly pan, mat, bucket or any other sort of hand-driven gravitational device. Some innovations are long-forgotten but merit attention. For instance, bars to keep the panners hand clear of the water, cables to hold large heavy pans, and several pans designed for panning without any water. Traditionally the North American gold pan was a combined digging and washing device, but today most models are not designed for digging and require a spade to be used. 
      Gold recovery in Gold Pans -the term... (PDF Download Available). Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/313562132_Gold_recovery_in_Gold_Pans_-the_term_'Panning'
       
    • By M1dn1ghtN1nj4
      I have been working on this for a couple weeks.  It's a collapsible, customizable, self-contained, super light, 3D printed sluice box!  I know there are other folding sluice boxes, but none of them actually fit in a backpack, or are light enough to carry in one hand.  This solution would be EXTREMELY helpful!
      I'm on my phone trying this, so when I get to my laptop, I'll write in a bit more.
       
       
      So I'm currently in the CAD stage.  I have a guy that does 3D printing for me, and his machine is limited to 12"x12"x15" so I might have to shrink the size of the project down to fit, as I don't have access to, or can even afford, a larger 3D printer.
      I have this up on Patreon to attempt to raise some funding to start getting prototypes printed, and boost this project towards the finish line!
      This is my Patreon page:
      https://www.patreon.com/M1dn1ghtN1nj4
    • By Sourdoughmoe
      Check out my new setup for those remote areas where gas powered engins aint allowed

×