Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Need Suggestions - Selling Gold Coins

Recommended Posts

I am down in the valley of AZ rite now for a family emergency what I need suggestions on is I have several 2.5 dollar gold pieces from the 1800s that I found while detecting a property I owned in Ohio I need to sell these gold coins so I can help my family out with this emergency can someone please tell me where to take these in AZ to sell them so I don't get ripped off as I do not know much about coins 


Thanks in advance for any and all suggestion

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Check Ebay....you will see what todays market on those coins are. Than you will have some idea of what to expect from yours. Grade and key dates and mint marks are key to getting top dollar. Good Luck !!

  • Like 2

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Be cautious, emergencies are the sellers worst enemy and the buyer's best friend...

If you can go to two or three coin shops and ask for an offer...

There is or was a forum member that buys gold...don't remember who he is....

btw; ordinary dates and worn coins will only be worth spot minus their cut...

maybe you should post them in the classifieds with pic's...?


  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, fredmason said:

maybe you should post them in the classifieds with pic's...?


let me try and take a few pics don't know about posting these on a forum classified section though not going to rush into anything until I know the value for myself I hate parting with them but family comes first every time, these were found under a house I owned and lived in while in Ohio in a huge crawl space the house and the year it was built is what got me into metal detecting the best finds I have ever made and in my mind would be hard to ever top it, they were found in a box buried in the crawl space abut 6 inches below the dirt floor back in one corner the box was full of coins I still have all including the box which was not in vary good condition as it was pretty damp in the crawl space,I have never said anything about this find to anyone other then family members that I trust, the house itself was built in the 1800s and like I said is what got me into metal detecting but you do what you have to just to help family so thus the reason for the sale    

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, DSMITH said:

Let me try and take a few pics don't know about posting these on a forum classified section....

You can simply post those photos right here on this thread and we can all share in the fun (I'm serious) of valuing them.

14 hours ago, DSMITH said:

(This find) ...got me into metal detecting the best finds I have ever made and in my mind would be hard to ever top it....

Hey, we all hear you on that -- there are many who have detected 40+ years and have never found a single gold coin let along a cache of them.  Right now (I'm really only a couple years experienced) I would be thrilled to find a silver half dollar.  While I'm at wishing, might as well make that a Walking Liberty..., 1921(any mint -- I'm not greedy)..., Extremely Fine condition....  :biggrin:

  • Haha 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/9/2017 at 10:42 AM, DSMITH said:

Can someone please tell me where to take these in AZ to sell them...?

There is an organization known as the Professional Numismatics Guild which has extremely strict requirements on ethics.  There are, of course, a lot of honest, ethical coin dealers who don't belong the PNG, but the chances of getting ripped off by a PNG member should be next to nil.  If you don't have time to shop around, this would be you best option, IMO.  They may not necessarily be in the position/need to buy you coins but I'm sure under the circumstances they would be happy to give you some indication of value and likely recommend someone who would want to buy them.  I searched thru their website (pngdealers.org) for PNG members in AZ and found these four.  The first guy (Grovich) sounds like the right guy, but I don't know how close you are to Carefree (which I think is ~25 miles north of Scottsdale).  The others could certainly advise and very likely appraise if they aren't interested in buying. Even if you aren't in driving distance I would at least call and tell them of your situation.  They will help.

Member No. 553 Since 12/31/1997
American Federal Rare Coin & Bullion
P.O. Box 5810
Carefree, AZ 85377-5810 United States
Hours: 8am-5pm MST
Phone: (800) 221-7694, (480) 553-5282
Fax: (480) 553-5290
Specialties: We trade in all types of gold, silver and platinum bullion. We specialize in buying and selling both rare and bullion type coins. Cash offers. We purchase all types of coins from Indian cents to proof gold. We will travel to inspect collections and pay on the spot, or you can take advantage of our Consignment Program.
Member No. 682 Since 08/09/2010
World Numismatics LLC
P. O. Box 5270
Carefree, AZ 85377 United States
Hours: 8am-4:30pm Mon-Fri
Phone: (480) 921-2562, cell (602) 228-9331
Fax: (480) 575-1279
Specialties: Mexico and Latin America
PNG Awards: Robert Friedberg Award - 2010
Member No. 707 Since 05/18/2012
Eagle Eye Rare Coins, Inc.
P.O. Box 32891
Tucson, AZ 85751 United States
Hours: 9-5 Mon-Fri in store
Phone: (520) 498-4615, (866) 323-2646
Fax: (520) 529-1299
Specialties: Flying Eagle and Indian Cents, Eagle Eye Photo Seal
Member No. 760 Since 09/02/2014
Tucson Coin & Autograph
6350 N. Oracle Rd.
Tucson, AZ 85704 United States
Phone: (520) 219-4427
Fax: (520) 797-1482
  • Like 5

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks everyone for all the info trying to get a clear enough pic of some of them with my phone which is not the best gonna try to find someone with a good camera have taken photos about 10 times with my phone of them and every time they look really blurry couldn't make heads nor tails out of the photos

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By foreverteachable
      I used baking soda and water to clean the coins since I don't plan on selling them.

    • By DukeBoxer
      The other day I made a spreadsheet to calculate MELT value of all my finds, I pull most of the info from coininfo.com and then spot prices of precious metals from Money Metals Exchange. I pull over 35% nickels, 90% dimes, 90% quarters, 90% halves and because I found one, 80% Candian quarter prices, plus 9, 10, 14, and 18k gold. Under the PM spots there's a sterling silver per gram conversion and then there are some bullion prices (These I think are dealer bid prices, so lower than normal) and along with those, a sterling/ounce price. It is made with google sheets but I'm sure you can export it to excel format (or even LibreOffice Calc). The prices are not live, but they do update each time you open the file. Here is a link to check it out and copy it for yourself. Below everything you'll see 2 cells with the formula for "American Silver Eagle". I left that there to test pulling in other info from the website. If anyone wants an explanation on how to add different things just let me know. Later today I will try to explain here
    • By Norm S
      I cashed in my clad at coinstar this afternoon. I have had my 800 for 6 weeks and my 600 for about 3 weeks. 
      I cashed in at coinstar for a total of $172.66.. I had quit counting what I had after I knew I had almost $100 but never dreamed I had as much as I had. 
      I have to admit I hit a cpl awesome parks and even though they had been hunted recently I cleaned up. I actually believe there is more at the one park but in an area I gridded I only found about $3 in two hours. In an area the other guy missed I found $9 in clad in a 30' x 30' area bordered by a sidewalk. 
      I also hunted 3 other areas that I had hit really hard with both my Etrac and V3i. One soccer field that I took over $100 out of the past cpl of years I must have really cleaned it out because I found 3 cents. Another area I had hit hard with the Etrac before i got the Equinox. That area I found 40 cents. The last area which was a park that is hunted all the time I found 70 cents in 3 hours.
      I hunted an old soccer field yesterday and everything was deep.I had been there with my Etrac and only found a cpl of dimes and a nickel. Everything I found was 8" or more with the exception of a cpl surface pennies. I pulled out $3.48 in about 2 hours.. I have a cpl more places on my radar as well. I like hunting parks that others have hunted because it makes me feel the Equinox is superior to other detectors but in reality I think it the person that was detecting didn't know his detector very well.
      I also have 2 silver rings and a silver pendent. 
    • By DukeBoxer
      Something just popped into my mind and I thought I'd ask everyone...has anyone ever taken a found ring to a jeweler and had them re-finish it and shine it up so that they could then sell it for significantly more than they would've gotten for it at melt? I was wondering if doing this would be (more) profitable...found ring is worth $x in melt value + $y to make it sparkle. Could the value of a nice shiny new ring be greater than $x+$y. I know things are only worth what someone would pay for it but maybe just maybe...
    • By Bhogg
      Hi All
      I’m in an area that’s got some pretty sandy ground and some of the coins especially the copper coins are pretty much unrecognisable and even the slivers are very badly stained with a blackish look to them.
      So I’m just wondering what seems to work the best to bring them back to life so they resemble what they should look like?, I don’t expect them to look fantastic due to how bad there condition is in now but it’d be great to at least be able to recognise what they are.
      Any help would be greatly appreciated.
    • By Steve Herschbach
      Credit for this info goes to johndoe here.
      This is the app I use.. https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/coinflation-gold-silver/id535653219?mt=8 
      Here is there website.... http://www.coinflation.com
      The phone app has melt values for junk gold and silver.