Jump to content
Rob Allison

My Thoughts On The X Coil

Recommended Posts

Hey Steve,

    You and I have known each other for a long time, even had some great times metal detecting together.  That being said, the X-coils at this point scare me off.  I had an opportunity a month or so ago to test several different sizes from someone that is affiliated with the manufacture.  I was a bit excited at first, then found out I would have to cut/modify an adapter/chip from another GPZ coil to use one of the X-coils.  

To me, the trade off to damage or destroy a $600 - $1500 coil to just get an adapter to work on an X-coil is not my cup of tea.  I don't need a smaller coil that bad to do this.  That being said, other guys like to modify/fix/tinkle or whatever might enjoy this.  

I find the GPZ 7000 stock coil plenty sensitive enough to find gold down to a grain in size.  However, a smaller coil like an 11" or so would be nice for tighter areas or areas with more vegetation.  

We were kind of promised a smaller coil originally from Minelab and that never happened.  I think one more smaller coil from Minelab would have eliminated most of this stuff about smaller coils. 

Keep in mind, at one point I sold more Coiltek searchcoils across the US than any other dealer.  I could probably sell a ton of the X-coils, but not at the cost of sacrificing a detectors warranty.  

For the benefit of all GPZ owners, I hope someone like Coiltek, Nuggetfinder, Minelab, X-coils or whoever can find a better way to make a coil that will just plug right into the GPZ and work.  

Just my thoughts,

Rob Allison

 

 

  • Like 9

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Steve,

   No problem on moving the thread.  Another point I had was -

The money to justify another coil to find smaller gold, smaller than what the stock 14x13 can find, in my opinion is not worth it.  I have seen several threads of guys with a smaller X-coil that are now finding dinks.  

My overall mentality is, do I want to go back to old spots and find 1-2 grams of dinks hunting all day, or just concentrate my effort going forward exploring new ground in hopes for more sizable gold.  I guess it comes down to time, as mine is very limited so the risk/reward for me is to concentrate on new spots and potential of larger gold with the stock GPZ 14x13.  

I have played this game, chasing smaller gold with smaller coils for over 20 years now, going back to the SD series, GP series, GPX series, and should I do it again with the GPZ ...... :blush:

Rob Allison

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rob, I do notice that you usually come up with good sized gold.

I can remember when I was dredging in the late 70's with an older fella, he constantly used to throw away everything left on the carpet after he took off "the pickers." He would say "well Dave, it's fine gold, who wants fine gold?" I always remember that when I'm out there in 90 degrees scounging for a flake or two so I won't be skunked. In other words I totally agree with you.

A small coil would be great for rocky or tight areas, but your point is well made.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Like flak I mainly wanted a small coil for getting into tighter locations where the 14” won’t fit. Between rocks and in Nevada the thick sagebrush areas. I am content to wait for something that just plugs in, but I also think anyone that wants to give these coils a go... well more power to them.

But for normal use I agree the 14” hits plenty small while still giving the depth on larger gold and covering the ground. And it comes with the detector. :smile: I learned myself a long time ago if I want weight I have to hunt for larger gold. I can always find gold looking for tiny bits, but then that’s what I tend to find... tiny bits.

This all could have been avoided by Minelab delivering on the small coil. Clearly they can be made, even if it means some sort of compromise.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Steve Herschbach said:

This all could have been avoided by Minelab delivering on the small coil. Clearly they can be made, even if it means some sort of compromise.

I'm still mystified by this decision - and clearly it was a decision, that's not something you 'forget' to do. ML would have made quite a bit of money imho, I can't imagine anyone with a GPZ who wouldn't want one. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't want a smaller coil, I have an SDC for that.

I want a bigger coil. I had the 19" which I had good success with but it was a specialized coil for deeper ground...not a prospecting coil especially due to it's weight.

I want a larger coil I can both hit deeper ground with plus hopefully step it out prospecting with.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
46 minutes ago, flakmagnet said:

I'm still mystified by this decision - and clearly it was a decision, that's not something you 'forget' to do. ML would have made quite a bit of money imho, I can't imagine anyone with a GPZ who wouldn't want one. 

Mystified?  Madtuna answers it right below your post …  :)

16 minutes ago, madtuna said:

I don't want a smaller coil, I have an SDC for that.

I don't know if it would compete with the SDC, but my guess is that it would be close enough. The 14x13 in  my opinion gets the same size gold, just a little shallower.  Now you give a smaller coil and that SDC has competition.  Minelab probably doesn't want to compete with other products that are still going well.  My .02.

Andyy

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that small coil would have hurt SDC sales and probably have very similar performance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Andyy said:

I don't want a smaller coil, I have an SDC for that.

But why would someone with a GPZ want to pay  $3750 for essentially a smaller coil? I guess that's considered "good business" but I don't necessarily agree.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By phrunt
      I often wondered why X-coils came out of Russia, I know Russia has a big interest in metal detectors and has a large user base of metal detectors but I always assumed it was relics and coins that were big there like in a lot of Europe.  I never knew Russia was a country with a lot of gold.  Then I looked it up and to my surprise Russia is the 3rd largest gold producer in the world.  
      A caption from a website about Russian Gold.
      Russia recently established itself as the 3th largest gold producing nation in the world, behind China and Australia. With over 11% of the earth’s total land mass, Russia is also estimated to have the 3rd largest gold reserves in the world, with much of that gold yet to be recovered. An archaic regulatory process has limited development of many lode resources throughout the country by various mining companies. Despite these setbacks, Russia is considered to have some of the best potential for future development for gold mining in the coming decades.

      You'll see in 2018 Russia was only just behind Australia in gold production with China in first place.  Sadly New Zealand doesn't even make the list 😞
      Russia is also known for very large nuggets, some of the known big nuggets are:
      A 14-pound gold nugget called the “Devil’s Ear Nugget” was discovered in 2014.
      A 22-pound gold nugget was found as recently as 2017.
      Russia’s largest gold nugget – a 79-pounder was found in the southern Ural Mountains.
      You can read about it on this website
      Now that I know these facts it's no surprise at all X-coils came from Russia,  It's also no surprise that the manufacturer of the X-coils is himself a prospector, and a very successful one too.
      Here is a couple of videos of him finding some large nuggets using the 12" Spiral wound X-coil on his GPZ.
      And some of the Gold he found recently.


      Now it all makes sense why the X-coils came from Russia.   It makes my little sub gram nugget finds look very tiny 🙂
       
    • By rasheede11
      My brothers members in this wonderful forum
      Can you tell me where to buy X-Coils gpz7000
      As well as patch cable gpz7000
      They are better than coils 14
    • By Condor
      Thanks to Davesgold and the X-Coil manufacturer, I got a gifted 17x12 Spiral Wound coil. The manufacturer took notice of my multitude of problems with the connector modification and sent me a new coil from Russia.  Bravo Zulu X-Coil for prospector support.  The weather has improved here in Sunny Yuma so I replaced the 17" round with the new coil and took it for a spin.  I balanced it over the ferrite with no problems and I experienced no bump sensitivity. 
      The first thing I noticed is how well the coil balances on my modified hip stick rig.  I do a lot of detecting in the walls of desert washes, putting the coil on its side.  The 7000 tends to get the "wee waas" if you don't keep them flat, but this coil seemed to really tone it down and it balanced really nice for less strain on my arm and shoulder.  On relatively flat ground I think I could swing this coil all day for less wear and tear on my 65 yr old frame.  I ultimately didn't find anything in the walls, but I hit some old hillside drywash tailings and popped these 3 nuggets.  All were at moderate depths but I was amazed at some of the deep iron bits I found.  Without some side by side target comparisons I can't say that my depth is improved, but I'm getting a lot better ground coverage and I can poke it in between rocks and obstructions.  Even if this coil is no better than the original Minelab 14", it's a lot more versatile.   This will be my go to coil from here on.  I'll stick the 17" round on over worked out patches, but this is my new secret weapon.
      Again, many thanks to Davesgold and X-Coil
       

    • By Chet
      I did the Minelab cable cutting and soldering differently than specified by the manufacturer.
      Instead of cutting the cable near the Minelab connector I cut it below the Minelab curled cord and installed the 5 pin connector at that location.
      After the connector was installed and marine grade shrink tubing was applied a plastic tie wrap was attached with another piece of shrink tubing. This is used to pull the cable out of the lower end of the upper shaft since the Minelab curled cord retracts it out of reach.
      I then used a heat gun to soften and straighten approximately 8 inches of the lower X Coil curled cord. Cut it at that point and attached a new connector at 8” above the lower shaft.
      I have all three X Coils setup with three new lower shafts attached. This modification allows quick easy change of coils in couple of minutes.
      It is reasonable to be concerned about interference from the two connectors being located so close to the coil. This is not a problem since the detector only detects motion change relative to the coil.
      A simple experiment will demonstrate how the detector nulls out metal that is not changing position relative to the coil.
      Place a small test target on the ground with an aluminum soda or beer can about 2 feet from it. Swing the detector over the small test target. You will only hear the response from the large can.
      Now tape the can on top of the detector shaft 2 feet from the center of the coil. Now swing the coil over the test target and it will be detected.
      With the can attached the detector it will sound off as you lift and lower the detector to the ground since the coil is remaining flat while the shaft and can are changing position relative to the coil.
      In normal detecting when setting the detector down or lifting it I hear this sound-off with the 17” x 12” coil but not with the 10” or the 17” round coils.
      There is no effect during normal detecting since the coil is not tilting or changing position relative to the shaft.
      Have a good day,
      Chet
       

    • By Norvic
      I have just come out of a magic winter season with the 10,12,15 X coils, I have not used my ML14 or 19 since putting them on. The X coils have made the Magic GPZ7000 a super magic detector. No teething problems, make patch lead, fit and dig gold. How good is that??? Can only say it doesn`t get any better...……...or does it. What will the X coils evolve into ????????? 
      I have no connection to X coil, or to Davsgold except as a customer, top coils, top service and express freight.
    • By phrunt
      A package I've been very much looking forward to arrived in the mail today, I call them the twins.  It made sense to package them both in one package for postage reasons and fortunately JW was working doing some renovations at his house around the corner from mine today so he had his a few minutes after the courier arrived at my place with the package as I shot straight over to give it to him. 
      I tore the box open to find them extremely well packaged


      And now the twins

      15x10 spiral wound X-coils, one for the GPZ, one for the GPX.  The GPZ's coils curly cord seems good to me.

      They came with a spare coil cover.  This is obviously the GPZ coil.

      And the GPX one.
      Hopefully I can find some gold soon with it, I've on a dry spell at the moment, although the football field of coins has kept me busy.  It's been about a month since I've attempted to find gold as my weekends are filled with skiing as my daughter is addicted to it and my week days have been busy doing the local coin hunting, now this coil has arrived I best get out there soon.  It snowed yesterday and today there is a freezing wind blowing off the snow, if it wasn't for that I'd be shooting off now to test it out.  Only about 2 weeks left of ski season.
      JW's been doing pretty well lately with his 10x9" X-coil and he rarely takes it off he loves it so much so it will be interesting to see how he goes with this new one being spiral (flat wound) when his 10x9" is bundle wound. 
×
×
  • Create New...